By Alan Scherstuhl
By Charles Taylor
By Melissa Anderson
By Inkoo Kang
By Amy Nicholson
By Sam Weisberg
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Chuck Wilson
John Irving's 1989 bestseller, A Prayer for Owen Meany, is a coming-of-age saga set during the period of the war in Vietnam. Irving examines big issues of God, country, and personal responsibility from the perspective of Owen Meany, whose outsider positionhe's less than four feet tallfuels his intensely personal quest for meaning. Owen Meany never settles for a received idea, whether from church or state, left or right.
With typical Hollywood antipathy toward politics and history, Simon Birchthe film "suggested" by the novel Irving sold to Disneyexpunges Vietnam from the narrative. (After reading the screen adaptation, Irving refused to allow his hero's name to be used in the film.) Director Mark Steven Johnson, who also scripted, sets Simon Birch in generic small-town U.S.A. at some vague time in the past. We know it's the past because the film opens with Jim Carrey, who plays Simon's best friend Joe now grown up, musing at Simon's grave: "I am doomed to remember a boy with a cracked voice... because he's the reason I believe in God." (I guess Irving had no choice, since he pocketed Disney's money, but to let them use a couple of his good lines.) After that we're in glowingly lit flashback. It's Gump-a-la-la-Landor so the folk at Disney's Hollywood Pictures must have hoped.
Written and directed by Mark Steven Johnson
A Hollywood Pictures release
Opens September 11
That Simon Birch is not as maudlin as it might have been is largely due to the intensely thoughtful, prickly performance of 11-year-old Ian Michael Smith, who plays Simon. Smith has Morquio syndrome, an enzyme-deficiency disease that causes dwarfism along with many painful bodily disorders. But it's not Smith's appearance that makes him such a compelling screen presence. It's his awareness of the split between his mind and his body and his ability to transcend his limitations by moving the film into a space that's energized more by brain power than physicality.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!