By Steve Weinstein
By Bryan Bierman
By Lindsey Rhoades
By Chaz Kangas
By Ben Westhoff and Sarah Purkrabek
By Jena Ardell
By Jesse Sendejas Jr.
By Katherine Turman
Seven years later, we know sampled jazz never materialized into the musical tomorrow. (It's savvy hustlers slangin' street-corner fantasies who make the dollars now.) Gang Starr's and Dream Warriors' careers went in separate directionspaths vividly displayed on two recent retrospectives, Gang Starr's Full Clip: A Decade of Gang Starr and Dream Warriors' Anthology: Decade of Hits 19881998.
Hip-hop "careers" are usually so short-lived, it seems silly to even use the word. But Gang Starr's DJ Premier and Guru have, for 10 years, proved a model of consistency and quality rivaled by no one (except, per haps, De La Soul). Just ask any group raised on their ethicthe Roots, Black Star, Organized Konfusion. Full Clip is an essential compendium of Gang Starr's influential existence through five albums, but it also at tests that labeling Gang Starr as part of the jazzhip-hop movement was a limiting misnomer. Sure, DJ Premier regularly culled bop-bitties from dusty crates; Guru essayed jazz's history on "Jazz Thing" for Spike Lee's Mo' Better Blues, and his Jazzmatazz experiments linked generations of musicians; and the two even lived with Branford Marsalis for a spell. But every deft Premier scratch and smooth but street-savvy Guru lyric reinforces the fact that, really, this DJ and MC were the ultimate embodiment of hip-hop's essencethe sonics and styles of jazz were just colors on their pallette
Anthology: Decade of Hits 1988–1998
It's Premier who has guided Gang Starr through hip-hop's different eras, making everything sound both relevant and remarkably ground breaking. He could flip hard-bop sounds into something positively thuggish (Charles Mingus on "I'm the Man"), transform eastern horns into a DJ's best friend ("Who's Gonna Take the Weight"), and make an obscure sample from French synth pioneer Jean Jacques Perrey sound essential to hip-hop ("Just To Get a Rep"). As for Guru, he fits with Premier's sonic wonderment so tenaciously that in any other scenario, he's a fish floundering out of water. "Wild with my monotone style/because I don't need gimmicks," he boasts, addressing his powerfully understated rhyming presence in "Mass Appeal." "Give me a fly beat and I'm all in it."
As Full Clip shows, Gang Starr's music occupies even the nooks and crannies of hip-hop idealism: they understand the importance of the B-side (the drum-heavy "Credit Is Due" or the party-rockin' "Dwyck"), and "Gotta Get Over," from the forgettable film Trespass, is far from the typical rap-soundtrack throwaway. The duo even survived hardcore hip-hop's greatest transgressionthe r&b cameoby making two hits with K-Ci & Jo-Jo ("Royalty") and Total ("Discipline"), the latter a new song that shows Gang Starr operation is in no danger of slowing down.
The legacy of King Lou and Capital Q of Dream Warriors, by contrast, never extended beyond the initial possibility of their coolly crafted debut, And Now the Legacy Begins, and their only legitimate hit single, "My Definition of a Boombastic Jazz Style" (which used the same Quincy Jones composed "Soul Bossa Nova" later employed in Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery). Their claim of possessing a decade's worth of "hits" rings resolutely hollow, even more so given that their first single was re leased only nine years ago. Compared to Gang Starr's collection, Anthology isn't a glorious remembrance; it's a tombstone. It's a symbolic gesture showing just how fleeting the jazz-rap future was (and why groups like Di gable Planets and US3 are just memories). Dream Warriors were jazzhip-hop entities only insomuch as they sampled jazz.
Outside of the three tracks Dream Warriors include from their first album, you'd be hard-pressed to recognize anything on their best-of. A handful of songs from the group's lackluster second effort, and new songs recorded n recent years (but not released in the U.S.), reveal major identity problems in the wake of hip-hop's changing stylesa group filling the subtext void with pseudo-spiritual imagery, hokey New Age concepts, and contrived beatnik rhyming pat terns. Interestingly, the Dream Warriors included their lone post-Legacy highlight, "I've Lost My Ignorance," on their retrospectivethe DJ Premier remix version, at that. But on their compilation, Gang Starr did not. They didn't need to. Their clip was already loaded.
Gang Starr play Hammerstein Ballroom