By Michael Atkinson
By Luke Winkie
By Steve Weinstein
By Brian McManus
By Brian McManus
By Dan McQuade
By Dan McQuade
By Brian McManus
Fancy a Shagg?
Thirty years after their father inverted the generation gap and forced them to become a rock and roll bandof sortsthe Shaggs made their New York City debut at the Bowery Ballroom last weekend, joining the celebration of another 30th anniversary: their longtime champions NRBQ. With mother Annie in attendance, Dorothy and Betty Wiggins, joined by Q drummer Tommy Ardolino (filling in for the convalescent Helen), played just four songs in what, even so, felt like a comprehensive overview: "Philosophy of the World," the title track of their debut album, rescued from oblivion in 1980 and then given a major label imprimatur this year; "Painful Memories" and "My Cutie," from the later recording Shaggs Own Thing ; and their legendary "My Pal Foot Foot."
Dorothy still wears her hair long, like in those precious band photos; apologetic for their clumsiness but more than game, she seemed as comfortable in front of the audience as, I dunno, Mary Margaret O'Hara, chatting in a voluble New England accent better embodied in the Shaggs' droned harmonies than any rock save Jonathan Richman. Betty, who's cut her hair back severely, looked more nervous, but when she sang her Fastbacks-esque girl-group lament "Painful Memories," mouth anesthetized in that Richard Hell way, she stole the show. The Shaggs were actually the least silly performers in a two-day fest that also included the gibbering Holy Modal Rounders, costumed Sun Ra Arkestra, and far shaggier NRBQ. Their out-of-tune guitars are now in tune (Sonic Youth tune), their mixture of repression and cutesiness no different than Shonen Knife. The set may have been folk art, equal parts goofy and eerie, but it brought home why the Shaggs' Rorschach blottings were eventually read as visions, rough sketches for the future of underground rock. Eric Weisbard
Making the Cut
Producer Hal Willnerlike the late Harry Smith, whose imponderably influential Anthology of American Folk Music was honored at Arts at St. Ann's November 11is himself a most canny curator, collector, and taste maven. As demonstrated by his Monk and Mingus projects, Willner possesses both a formidable Rolodex as well as a knack for matching musicians to material. But while any decent jazzbo should be able to cover Monk, it takes a certain wild-hair bravado to tackle highly idiosyncratic popular music by long-lost artists of the '20s and '30s like Cubby Parker, Uncle Eck Dunford, and Bascom Lamar Lunsfordmusic already at least once removed from its dubious source. So the question hanging in the air during the patience-testing four-hour marathon was: Which of these performances might have qualified for Smith's 1952 anthology?
Former Virgin Prune Gavin Friday, who tore up "When That Great Ship Went Down" alongside Mary Margaret O'Hara, would have been a contender. Likewise Peter Stampfel, who, accompanied by Gary Lucas, broke format with an original song characterizing Smith as a "genius, shaman, pain-in-the-ass." Nick Cave transcended his shtick for a roof-raising version of Blind Willie Johnson's "John the Revelator," while Van Dyke Parks was seemingly everywhere on piano and accordion. Kate and Anna McGarrigle, Geoff Muldaur, and Bob Neuwirth all took sober folky stabs at these songs of betrayal and murder. Trombonist Roswell Rudd and Sonic Youth transformed their improvisation around one of Smith's abstract films into conceptual art. And David Johansen and the Harry Smiths came off so fake as to be right in the pocket. But in the end, no one sounded more like a Harry Smith collectee than Smith himselfas seen on film at the very beginning, roach clutched in stained fingers, extemporizing a surreal chantey to the tune of "Dixie." Richard Gehr
It seemed like an army of NYU art students had been supplanted into the Bowery Ballroom for Warp's tenth anniversary last Friday, a sign of the label's shift from weirdy-beardy dance music to indie electronic pop. Home to beat anarchists like Aphex Twin, Autechre, and Squarepusher, Warp chose to spotlight its new, more mellow (and nerdy) roster instead, with Plone, Broadcast, and Plaid.
Plone provided the evening's most unusual sounds: kiddie melodies wrapped in barely-there beatsand few vocals. Unlike labelmates Boards of Canada, who convey similarly childlike fairytales, Plone chose not to contrast the light airiness of the music with a seedy underbelly. Calling Plone dance music would be incorrect; the most you could do was sway in motion. Everything about Broadcast was vague: the music was vaguely psychedelic, in a '60s lounge way; singer Trish Keenan had a vaguely intriguing stage presence and a vaguely interesting voicesmooth, clean, but detached. Broadcast were a little bit Stereolab and a little bit Mazzy Star but ultimately not enough of anything.
Plaid offered relief from the previous two bands' soft melodies. Beats emerged decisively: clear and crisp, carving out huge, hook-laden grooves of future funk. Filtering hip-hop through a distinctly British vantage point,the trio toyed with the bpm's and staked firm musical ground with its infectious breakbeats, though sometimes you'd hear the Warp of olde. Aphex Twin was present in spiritespecially when Plaid delved into unorthodox beat structures and erratic time signatures. The crowd responded by dancing (the first time all evening); the geeks might yet inherit the earth. Tricia Romano