By Anna Merlan
By Anna Merlan
By Julie Seabaugh
By Jon Campbell
By Albert Samaha
By Anna Merlan
By Alex Distefano
By Scott Snowden
Stand at the waterfront near Kent Avenue and Grand Street in Williamsburg, and you get an eyeful of both the neighborhood's vitality and its industrial congestion. On one corner sits Radiac, a tidy one-story building that just happens to be a low-level radioactive waste facility. Across the street is Domino Sugar, its Dickensian brick building home to a bitter, nearly two-year union strike over issues that included accusations of asbestos poisoning. To the south there is the Norval Cement Plant and the Schaeffer Brewery. About a mile to the north is the Newtown Creek Sewage Treatment Plant.
Along the waterfront, there are high levels of lead in the ground and extensive contamination from waste-transfer stations, dry-cleaning plants, and coal-tar deposits. According to the the city's Department of Health, the incidence of asthma in Brooklyn is four times the national average; of the five boroughs, it has the highest rate of two kinds of childhood leukemia.
Yet Williamsburg, home to thriving Hasidic, black, Polish, and Latino communities, a much-hyped new artists' bohemia, multiple public and parochial schools, city parks, and several huge public housing complexes, has been targeted by the New York Power Authoritya state agency whose job it is to build power plantsand a private company that hopes to quietly site a power turbine and a power barge in the already beleaguered neighborhood.
In its environmental assessment, the Power Authority described the neighborhood as "industrial" and lacking "open space," as if Williamsburg's environmental travails justified even greater exploitationit's dirty, so let's build more dirty things here. The privately funded power barge, NISA, is scheduled for Wallabout Channel nine blocks from the NYPA turbine. If the Power Authority and NISA succeed, they will bring the total number of power plants within a 10-block radius to three. These plants will annually blow hundreds of tons of additional airborne pollutants over preschools, yeshivas, public and parochial schools, and Independence Towers, home to an estimated 11,300 people.
The Power Authority argues that these plants, and additional ones planned for other working-class neighborhoods, are urgently needed to forestall a California-sized power crisis come summer 2001. But a burgeoning coalition of local activists disagrees.
A borough-wide network of neighborhood groups has formed to take on both the Power Authority and the agencies that issue the siting and air permits allowing them to fast-track turbine construction. Organized city-wide as CURE (Communities United for Responsible Energy), member organizations in Williamsburg include Williamsburg Watch, El Puente, Neighbors Against Garbage, and Stop the Barge. Together, they have filed suit in state supreme court to stay the building of the turbines pending environmental impact studies. In so doing, the issue of environmental justice has been placed front and center, as has the longtime practice of siting industry in low-income neighborhoods that already bear enormous industrial hardships.
"There has always been a lot going on in Williamsburg because things are so bad here environmentally," says Deborah Masters, an artist and activist who is director of Stop the Barge and community liaison at the Newtown Creek Sewage Treatment Plant. "But the power plants have lit up people I would never have thought would be interested. We're meeting all kinds of different people, and together we're working on this thing that's very important. It's been a fabulous experience for me.
"I had experienced a lot of health problems myself as a result of pesticide poisoning," says Masters. "Then I became an artist and I got cadmium poisoning from grinding paint off sculpture, which I had no idea about. Then I got lead poisoning from the Manhattan Bridge when they sandblasted it. That's when I got really sick. I realized at some point that because I lived in a certain part of Brooklyn, basically I was poor, so the quality of the air I was breathing didn't matter to anybody. I got empowered over the incinerator."
Masters's neighborhood has a history of environmental activism: For the past 20 years, community groups have been fighting battles throughout Williamsburg and Greenpoint, a combined area considered by the Department of Environmental Conservation and the Department of Environmental Protection to be one of the most environmentally burdened 4.8 square miles in the nation. In the '90s, residents from the area's Hasidic and Hispanic communities formed an unlikely alliance to block construction of a garbage incinerator at the Brooklyn Navy Yard. The Toxic Avengers, part of the Latino community organization El Puente, drew attention to Radiac. The Watchperson Project, an organization formed to map environmental data in the area, was established after the state Department of Environmental Conservation fined the city $850,000 for leaking waste into Greenpoint's already anaerobic Newtown Creek, a violation of the Clean Water Act. Neighbors Against Garbage (NAG) formed to fight waste transfer stations. The illegal lead-paint removal from the Williamsburg Bridge prompted a successful five-year lawsuit, though not before, according to two department of health studies, 375 Brooklyn children had been poisoned.
The New York Power Authority has gone to great lengths to reassure the public that the turbines are clean-burning, but what power plants emit and what the cumulative impact of those emissions will be on the air quality of a neighborhood are two very different things.