By Alan Scherstuhl
By Amy Nicholson
By Melissa Anderson
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Alan Scherstuhl
By Alan Scherstuhl
By Charles Taylor
By Melissa Anderson
The surprise Japanese air raid on the American fleet that provides the premise for Memorial Day's supreme blockbuster, Michael Bay's $140 million Pearl Harbor, was a 90-minute attack that destroyed eight battleships and seven other boats, as well as 188 airplanes. Some 2400 Americans were killed and nearly half as many wounded. The Japanese lost 29 planes and fewer than 100 men.
Unlike the remake, the Pearl Harbor of December 1941 occurred in a media black hole. That this crippling debacle was recorded at all is largely due to the coincidental presence of the Fox Movietone camera crew in Hawaii to shoot background for a John Payne programmer, To the Shores of Tripoli. The footage was held for 11 weeks and then, per navy policy, shown only after all pictures of actual combat were deleted. A complete version was cleared a full year after the raid, but it was not until 1943, when John Ford and Gregg Toland's largely restaged (and massively hacked) "documentary" December 7th was released, that the catastrophe received definitive screen form. Until now?
Pearl Harbor recasts the story as myth. A pair of corn-fed farm kids playing dogfight with daddy's crop duster grow up to be daring flyboys Ben Affleck and Josh Hartnett, waiting for the U.S. to join the war already raging in Europe. Enter a bevy of teenage nurses, anachronistically chattering about soldier butt. An elaborate medical meet-cute puts the wooden Affleck in exciting proximity to Kate Beckinsalea raven-maned thoroughbred with a sensational '40s wardrobe. Everyone is bound for the peaceful base in Pearl Harbor until Affleck volunteers to help the RAF. Soon he's flying missions over the English Channel while Beckinsale pines for him on Diamond Head.
A Real Young Girl
Written and directed by Catherine Breillat, from her novel The Air Duct
Opens June 1
Farewell, Home Sweet Home
Written and directed by Otar Iosseliani
June 1 through 7
Meanwhile, the Japanese conspire, robotically declaiming their attack plan to the sound of pounding kettle drums. Hollywood's last trip to Pearl, the ill-fated 1970 epic Tora! Tora! Tora!, treated World War II as a sort of international coproduction, being half shot from the Japanese point of view. Here the stereotypes are in place, although a discreet nod to American economic pressure on Japan, not to mention the tactful omission of any reference to Japanese atrocities in China, betrays Disney's desire to maintain some credibility in the lucrative Japanese market.
A movie of strenuous romance and boisterous bonhomie, Pearl Harbor is constructed on the Titanic modelless a combat flick than a romantic disaster film that keeps you waiting for that asteroid to finally hit. "People in this outfit have way too much time on their hands," Beckinsale complains as she prepares to embark on a new romance with the puppyish Hartnett. Randall Wallace's scenario hopefully floats a few whoppingly unlikely personal complications while churning the never limpid waters of bureaucratic culpability. (Small solace to have ghostbuster Dan Aykroyd cast as the lone intelligence officer who saw the attack coming.)
Arriving just past midpoint in the 160-odd minute movie, the big blowout improves on the Ford-Toland re-creation, whichdespite its miniatures and rear screen projectionwas appropriated by later documentaries, even as it provided the template for Tora! Tora! Tora! and the 1983 miniseries The Winds of War. The sky above Pearl is thick with low-flying Japanese bombers. Digital explosions ripple the screen. Despite close-ups of trapped men and smashing metal, there's the dehumanized sense of hornets swarming over an overturned anthill. The chaos is convincing, but, less ruthless than Steven Spielberg, Bay eschews D-day panic and mutilation. The hospital madness goes mercifully misty at strategic momentsif not before it inspires speculation on how an ER might appear in a big-budget movie called Hiroshima.
Lasting half an hour, the Pearl Harbor scene encompasses a bit of payback as Affleck and Hartnett manage to get themselves airborne. The men in the water cheer this cowboy duo, although their success hardly compensates for the flaming, corpse-clogged harbor or the hordes of charbroiled soldiers storming the hospital. With nearly an hour to run, the movie has to resolve this bummer. Wallace's script paraphrases Tora! Tora! Tora!'s final lineAdmiral Yamamoto second-guesses his apparent victory, "I fear that all we have done is awaken a sleeping giant"and includes a large chunk of FDR's December 8 speech to Congress. Indeed, Roosevelt (an unrecognizable Jon Voight) is personalized as inspirational leader. Frustrated by perceived defeatism among his military advisers, he rises painfully from his wheelchair and says, "Do not tell me it cannot be done." Finally, the movie foists off Alec Baldwin (in Bruce Willis mode) as Jimmy Doolittle and tacks on an abbreviated Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo.
Neither D.W. Griffith nor Oliver Stone, the filmmakers are incapable of infusing history with soap opera immediacy. A backbeat of Christian sacrifice notwithstanding, the magnitude of the event overshadows the three stars (plus Cuba Gooding Jr.'s bone-throw turn as a ship's cook who boxes for his self-respect). Indeed, Beckinsale brought down the house at the heavily papered all-media screening with an explanation of her post-bombing mind-set. "I'm pregnant and I didn't even know until the day you turned up alive and then all this happened." Entwined as it is with the national self-image, the meaning of Pearl Harbor will necessarily be made by the audience.
Will this vision of the only time the U.S. was subject to aerial bombardment serve to promote the newfangled SDI fantasy? How could it not? "President" George W. Bush isn't much of a movie fan, but you don't have to be Criswell to predict that he'll have something nice to say about this hollow tubthumper.
Somewhat diagrammaticand definitely X-ratedCatherine Breillat's long-unreleased first feature, A Real Young Girl, is a philosophical gross-out comedy rudely presented from the perspective of a sullen, sexually curious 14-year-old. A Real Young Girl, which was made over a period of two years in the early '70s (and pointedly set in the months following May 1968), is a hymn of adolescent liberation. "I hate peoplethey oppress me," schoolgirl Alice (Charlotte Alexandra) muses on the train home for vacation.
The visual metaphor for her parents' farmhouse is the sticky ribbon of flypaper over the kitchen table. While Alice and the folks eat in silence, she secretly diddles herself with a spoonthen goes outside to wander aimlessly with her panties down around her ankles. Alice is also something of an intellectual. She pukes on herself and is inspired to write in her diary. Visiting the family chicken coop, she idly crushes an egg in her handmerging impulse behavior with what Marx once called the "idiocy of rural life."
Overstuffed with wildly tactile (if mainly autoerotic) sexual adventure, A Real Young Girl has an outrageously elemental quality. Breillat can't resist filming a dog carcass decomposing on a dirty beach. Alice spends her days lolling about in a bikini, flirting with her father, and picking wax out of her ears until she finds an object of desire in the person of the hunky hired hand (Fellini Satyricon star Hiram Keller). As fascinated by her bodily functions as she is, the round-faced, ample protagonist might be the subject of R. Crumb's fantasy "Gurl." Alexandra, who subsequently starred in Emmanuelle 3, is necessarily a bit older than the part she plays, but she carries off a demanding role with considerable aplombincluding performing in several spectacular fantasies as infantile as they are sexual.
Reinserted, so to speak, in film history, A Real Young Girl belongs with such mid-'70s post-porn provocations as John Waters's Pink Flamingos and Jean-Luc Godard's Numero Deux. It's a far better introduction to Breillat than her risible hardcore polemic Romanceand particularly timely in that the filmmaker has revisited the scene of adolescent sexuality in her sensational Fat Girl, likely to appear here in the fall.
Farewell, Home Sweet Home, written and directed by Otar Iosseliani, is a movie of mysterious maneuvers, both business and romantic. The ensemble is dispersed; such narrative as exists concerns a family of eccentrics (headed by the filmmaker himself) whose particular "home sweet home" is a stork-haunted chateau on the outskirts of Paris. Rich people want to be ordinary; ordinary people want to be special. No matter how bizarre, the comings and goings feel distanced, mainly for being in middle shot. Iosseliani's droll, elaborately off-handed sight gags amount to a sort of genteel circus. The movie exudes a cheerful energylaying out a deck of narrative cards, then reshuffling them in the final 10 minutes.
Farewell, Home Sweet Home's weeklong run (a U.S. premiere) inaugurates BAM's second annual series of movies culled from The Village Voice's Film Critics Poll of the year's best and best unreleased films. The latter category includes such must-sees as Chantal Akerman's The Captive, two features by Jia Zhangke (Xiao Wu and Platform), and Aleksei German's scabrous Khrustalyov, My Car!
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!