Free Appitizer
new york, NY 10003
Her voice hits you like a bracing blast of girl air: precocious, impatient, plucky, and utterly adolescent. Susie used to snap covert photos of her family while practicing to be a wildlife photographer and made ships in a bottle so she could hang out with her dad. She skipped class only once and almost kissed a boy named Ray. Susie dreamed of growing up and going to high school but never did. The Lovely Bones is the tale of her murder and its aftermath, a luminescent debut novel that does something rare in the world of fictionit conjures a fully realized imaginative universe that is both tangible and ethereal, creating a sublime friction between reality and ghostliness, the now and the nevermore.
This isn't a mystery story, since we know by page two that the killer is Mr. Harvey, a neighborhood eccentric who builds an underground cave to entrap Susie. She narrates the book from heaven, recalling her rape and murder with language and imagery that seem age appropriate: "I felt the corners of my body were turning in on themselves and out, like in cat's cradle, which I played with Lindsey just to make her happy."
For Sebold (whose previous book, Lucky, was a memoir about being raped as a college freshman), this murder is just the beginning of the story. Looking down from her perch in the clouds, Susie's perspective is both omniscient and off-kilter as she depicts Mr. Harvey lugging around a sack of her bones, sitting in his basement carving Gothic dollhouses, and making small talk with her parents. She also watches her family ricochet between denial and horrorthe parents growing distant from each other, and the siblings' carefree childhoods turning solemn. Sebold lays out family dynamics with delicate precision, illustrating the emotional costs of rebuilding and the impossibility of replicating the old structure.
At first Susie takes a selfish glee in seeing how much people miss her, but that excitement turns to frustration when she realizes that she can't console them. In the days after her disappearance, as her mother makes lists of what she was wearing, what objects she might have carried, Susie says, "I had wavered between the bittersweet joy of seeing my mother name all the things I carried and loved and her futile hope that these things mattered." As an escape from her family's misery, Susie spends a lot of her time mooning over her lost opportunity for romance by obsessively revisiting her one close encounter with Ray:
On my feet I had a pair of fake sheepskin boots with dirty synthetic shearing spilling out like animal innards around the tops and seams. If I had known this was to be the sex scene of my life, I might have prepared a bit, reapplied my Strawberry-Banana Kissing Potion as I came in the door.
Susie's version of heaven resembles the local high school she'd looked forward to attending, with a few differences: "We had been given, in our heavens, our simplest dreams. There were no teachers in the school. We never had to go inside except for art class. . . . The boys did not pinch our backsides or tell us we smelled; our textbooks were Seventeen and Glamour and Vogue." The idea of a place in the clouds where spirits watch over us has always seemed twee (not to mention overly optimistic), and the book does fall prey to a few celestial clichés. But this heaven has such a strong vibe, it feels as real as a mall or a classroom. Susie decorates her sky pad with literal wishful thinking (if she wants something, it appears) and sits in a gazebo spying on her old earth friends as if watching a personalized soap opera all day, using their activities and environments as raw material for her ghost world.
The Lovely Bones encompasses so many milieus so effortlesslyfrom the lonely lawns of heaven to the miniature humiliations of high school to the internal purgatory of a serial killer. The novel's structure is extremely intricate, weaving sickening horror between the manicured hedges of 1970s suburbia, yet it feels as organic as a blush spreading across one's face. Sebold maps pinpricks of emotion that radiate over the town's surface as people's memories of the dead girl or fears for their own children's safety flare up and then fade. One of the most affected is Ruth, a brainy classmate who, moments after the murder, is physically touched by Susie's soul as it leaves earth. Ruth spends the rest of her young life intercepting transmissions from slain women, testing the barrier between life and death, which turns out to be surprisingly porous. Susie finds she can occasionally make her presence felt, even haunting her killer's bloodstained dreams and memories as she attempts to understand him.
Sebold throws in some comic relief by making the morbidly obsessed Ruth a celebrity among Susie's neighbors in heaven, teasing that Ruth "would have been disappointed to know that often these fans, when they gathered, resembled more a bunch of teenagers poring over an issue of TeenBeat than Ruth's image of low dirgelike whisperings set to a celestial timpani."
the book was great and this review is the best
I feel like Alice Sebold owes me for the time I wasted reading this poorly written piece of airport "literature". I was tired of Susie, the narrator's, voice before I finished the first chapter. And guess what...it didn't get any better. I understand that 14 year-olds are self-involved, but really? From beginning to end, this dead girl (this author) assumed that everything in the world of the living still revolved around her. Many parents are unfortunate enough to lose children, and many siblings are torn up by it. But ten years? Ten years of everyone's lives revolving almost entirely around this dead girl (who doesn't seem at all distressed by the fact that they don't or can't move on...selfish). Also, Alice Sebold was raped in college. With that history, how can she possibly put forth that the dead rape victim's first act after possessing a living girl's body (I know...preposterous, and the book barely does a better job describing the logistics of that than I just have!) was to have sex with some guy (who misses her terribly...just like everyone else) she had a crush on in school (real life school...not to be confused with the "school" she "attends" in "heaven"...her heaven...not to be confused with real heaven, which, of course, is waiting for her until she is ready to leave her family behind...again). And don't let the name of the book fool you...there is very little to do with dead bodies, bones, police work or anything of the like in the book. Yes, there is an ongoing investigation into the young girl's rape and murder, but, as I said, there is very little police work actually being done. The "bones" are a poorly thought-out metaphor for the ties that connect us to those we love. And one would be hard-pressed to find anything to call lovely unless it's the fact that the book does eventually end. The author's style of prose is pretentious and feels artificial, and her insight is below average at best. I hope writing this book was therapeutic for her, because I believe that might be the best that could be said of it.
First, the book. I think Alice Sebold is a bold and clever writer, only not good enough to sustain the interest through to the end. The idea of writing from afterlife should be suspenseful and powerful, in which case I think its much debated comparison, Forgiving Ararat by Gita Nazareth, to fare better in terms of quality and the flow of plots. Movie-wise, it deteriorates further. The big ideas that were present in the book, albeit poorly constructed, were altogether absent from the movie. I was definitely hoping for more substance than just a plethora of CGI.
I really loved this book and am looking forward to seeing Peter Jackson's visual interpretation of it. The Lovely Bones was such a mesmerizing book I didn't want it to end. Skirting the borderlands between human reality and the imagined wonders of heaven, I felt I had been introduced to a world both startlingly tangible yet ethereal all the same. Since then, I have been looking for further excursions into the afterworld, but I haven't found much, until now. Recently I read Gita Nazareth's Forgiving Ararat. This book too explores the interconnections between the land of the living and the land of the dead. As a publicist and a fan of this book, I'm interested to see what parallels are drawn between the two.
Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...
Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...
More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience
Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info
Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips
Log in or Sign up
Social Connect:Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.
Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:
Sign Up or Log in
Social Connect:Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.
Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:
