By Jared Chausow
By Katie Toth
By Elizabeth Flock
By Albert Samaha
By Anna Merlan
By Jon Campbell
By Jon Campbell
By Albert Samaha
The first pill that officially allows women to menstruate once every three months, Seasonale is being positioned as a medical breakthrough. (Framed by four giant, reddish dots, Bushnell trumpeted "a whole new way" for women.) But similar combinations of estrogen and progesterone have long been marketed under other brand names. Women have been avoiding bleeding by staying on traditional birth control pills for months or even years, skipping each month's placebo doses. Even Seasonale's makers say having a period at the end of the product's three-month cycle serves no health purpose, but bleeding remains part of the package. It's as if too big an advance might overwhelm women used to a narrow range of birth control options.
Nevertheless, women are grateful for the baby step forwardif not for bringing down their breakup rates, then because Seasonale is reassuring proof that the pharmaceutical industry is finally coming up with new options. After more than 40 years of traditional pills, condoms, diaphragms, and sterilization dominating the stagnant landscape of pregnancy prevention, several recently approved methods have hit the marketa chewable, spearmint-flavored birth control pill, a range of new hormonal devices, and improvements on the IUD and cervical cap. Meanwhile, the backup pills known as emergency contraception are becoming more widely available. You might even call it a revolution, if it weren't a decade or two late in coming.
Women are embracing the advances, delayed and inadequate though they may be. "Our patients are happy with the new methods, but there's a long way to go," says Susan Sosa, director of clinical/surgical services at Planned Parenthood of New York City. "People are interested in easier, more convenient methods. They'd be happier if they fit their lifestyles better."
While the pill remains the most common reversible method, especially for women in their twenties, Sosa says her young patients are still excited about a wearable patch, approved last year, which releases hormones into the blood through the skin. Once a week for three weeks, women stick a fresh square, slightly bigger than a postage stamp, on their skin (butt or stomach placement would make it least visible, though Sosa says most of her patients put it on their shoulders). While it's more convenient than the pill, which has to be taken daily, Sosa says some complain that the patch slips around on their skin. And it comes in only one skin tone so fara pale, peachy color that stands out on darker skin.
A new vaginal ring, introduced last summer, is also growing in popularity. The roughly two-inch ring is 99 percent effective (which means that in clinical trials, one out of 100 women who used it for a year got pregnant). Like the patch, the ring releases hormones that make the body inhospitable to a pregnancy, but you have to put a new ring in only once a month.
Meanwhile, an improved IUD that lasts for five years and is less likely to cause side effects like cramps and bleeding has come to market. In March 2002, the FDA approved a one-size-fits-all, reusable cervical cap known as Lea's Shield. And a new hormonal implant, Implanon, is due out at the beginning of the year. Unlike the old Norplant system, Implanon contains only one tube and will stay implanted for three, rather than five, years.
Then there's the Today sponge, whose story speaks volumes about the desperation of birth control users. The sponge is known to get stuck inside, and its spermicide can irritate the vaginal lining. Even if women follow the several steps necessary to use itfirst running it under water and then leaving it in at least six hours after having sexthe sponge has a less than stellar success rate of about 90 percent.
Still, when the manufacturer of Today stopped making the over-the-counter method in 1995 because of factory problems (which apparently didn't seem worth correcting, given relatively modest sales) many women felt bereft. There was even a Seinfeld episode about the vanishing devices, with Elaine screening out guys who weren't "sponge-worthy." Not due back on U.S. shelves until at least February, the sponge went back on sale in Canada in March, and since then U.S. sponge fans have bought thousands online at around three American dollars apiece.
"The response we've had is incredible," says Barbara Bell, administrative manager of the Canadian website birthcontrol.com, which sells as many as 200 sponges a week to women in the U.S. and started an e-mail newsletter, The Spongeworthy Watch, catering to women pining for the device.
All these new options should cut into the unintended pregnancy rate, which now hovers at 49 percent of all conceptions. And with women terminating half of these unplanned pregnancies, a wider range of birth control methods could also lower the abortion rate, already at its lowest point since 1974. Indeed, emergency contraception, which can prevent pregnancy up to five days after unprotected sex, has been credited with preventing an estimated 51,000 abortions in 2000, according to the Alan Guttmacher Institute, a reproductive think tank.