By Christian Viveros-Fauné
By Miriam Felton-Dansky
By Tom Sellar
By Tom Sellar
By Jessica Dawson
By Tom Sellar
By R. C. Baker
By Tom Sellar
If Christopher Wheeldon's adventurous staging of the work for Pennsylvania Ballet strikes some as heretical or confusing, the reason has less to do with his choreography, most of which is adamantly classical and preserves many of the familiar dances to Tchaikovsky's gorgeous score, than with his concept and Adrianne Lobel's beautiful set. These both blur and expand the boundaries between outside and inside. The hero is a leading dancer cast as Siegfried; "outside"or the real worldis the rehearsal studio; "inside" is an arena for his imaginings about the ballet. The prince's search for an ephemeral romantic ideal of purity becomes a dancer's search for perfection and identification with his role.
The scene is a fin-de-siècle dance studio, unmistakably linked to Paris, where Swan Lake is being rehearsed (forget historical accuracy). In a wall-papered "room" with doors, barres, three sets of French windows, and an immense mottled mirror in a gold frame, Degas ballet girls with their bell-shaped white dresses and neck ribbons adjust their slippers and groom themselves. Wheeldon has tackled the studio or backstage atmosphere before (in his 1999 Scènes de Ballet and his 2001 Variations Serieuses); he must love the dialectic between process and performance. As Act I's festive opening dances begin, props are being taken from a hamper, the dancer (Tamara Hadley) who is to play the queen mother sits at the back reading a book, and seamstresses adjust costumes. The teacher (Pennsylvania Ballet stalwart Jeffrey Gribler bewigged like Jules Perrot) is to play the tutor, and the top-hatted abonné (Alexei Charov) who, with his favors, exerts control over the financially needy dancers, becomes the sorcerer who dominates the swans.
The dancer who is to play Siegfried (I saw Zachary Hench) not only displays his fine jumps, but plays hostwatching the charming peasant dances and bravura solos and ingenious threesome weavings of the pas de trois (Amy Aldridge, Martha Chamberlain, and Jermel Johnson on opening night), and dancing a polonaise briefly with a country girl on each arm to show a bit of democratic spirit.
It's while the Siegfried dancer, left alone at the end of rehearsal, is practicing some steps that the walls become translucent, the mirror reflects blue depths and vanishes, the French windows blow open, and forbidding gray-green water appears beyond the balcony. The dancer enters his own vision of the ballet.
Pennsylvania Ballet numbers only 40 dancers, and various factors mandated a single set. Between them, Lobel's decor and Wheeldon's skill at patterning make the space magical and flexible. As the familiar, slightly rearranged pas unfoldthe patterned flocking of the swans, Odette's solo, the dances for two "big" swans and four methodically scampery little ones, the magisterial and heart-stirring pas de deuxWheeldon has swans fly by behind the back "wall" or sit, posed, along the side corridors during the pas de deux. Natasha Katz's lighting turns the gauzy walls watery blue-green, but the fact that they are there at all reminds us of the porous boundaries between the dual dancing worlds. At one point Von Rothbart herds his swans like an exasperated ballet master.
Wheeldon, reared on the Royal Ballet's Swan Lake, preserves the mime in which Odette explains the magic spell to Siegfried. I also like the fact that the pas de deux is not conducted at the fashionable pace (so slow the musicians can hardly sustain the melody). It's touching the way the swans flock around their queen in a tableau that makes her the center of an immense living tutu. Of the company's three Odette-Odiles, I saw Riolama Lorenzo. She doesnt "act" love and despair. Wheeldon told the Dance Critics Association in a session during the organization's conference in Philadelphia that, since the Pennsylvania dancers didn't have the background in acting that he grew up with in the Royal, he preferred them to let the movement speak, as they do in the sizable Balanchine repertory that has graced the company since its inception in 1963 under Barbara Weisberger. Lorenzo is strong and pliant; when she arches backward in her partner's arms or stretches a leg high in an attitude, her body seems to blossom. Hench is excellent in his dancing and understated in the gestures he must keep making to vanishing women in white, the dreamer almost too bemused by his own dream.
Wheeldon's concept has its problems (it would have been useful, for instance, if the dancer playing Odette had appeared in Act I). A dancer alone in the studio is a likely candidate for dreaming; a dancer at a boisterous party in the studio, with drink flowing and ballet girls sitting around tables beside tailcoated admirers, is less likely to identify with his role. Goodbye Degas, hello Toulouse-Lautrec. Here, Wheeldon departs most strenuously from Petipa's choreography. No prospective brides for Siegfried. The Von Rothbart performer provides the entertainment, ushering in the acts like a sleazy cousin of The Nutcracker's Drosselmayer. The acts are sleazy too, or at least suggestive. As a woman in a long multi-layered white gown (Amy Aldridge) bourrées about in Tchaikovsky's slow, seductive Russian dance, roistering men pull strings attached to her garments until she's in her underwear. The Spanish dance is a trio for two seedy men (James Ihde and Brian Debes) and Tara Keating gotten up like Lautrec's La Goulue in a tight green satin dress. In the czardas, Meredith Rainey swings his partner, Valerie Amiss, into the air with vulgar gusto, and Tchaikovsky's Tarantella becomes a cancan for five women who appear to have imbibed a lot of absinthe.