By Amy Nicholson
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Calum Marsh
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Inkoo Kang
By Voice Film Critics
By Alan Scherstuhl
By Alan Scherstuhl
Many of Herzog's essays have a primal elementalism to them that suggests they could've happened in a pre-electronic- mediated world, or even within a pre-cinematic mind-set. Not so with Grizzly Manthe dirty fingerprints of celebrity hunger, 24-7 broadcasting, and nature-as-commodity market-think are all over it. Which is precisely why the stubbornly renegade Herzog is the righteous choice for reconsidering Treadwell's dismaying odyssey to the frontier. A failed actor, ex-surfer, and soul-searching recovered drinker, Treadwell found satisfaction and meaning establishing a grassroots preservationist organization on behalf of Alaskan grizzlies and, most vitally, spending 13 long summers living unarmed among the animals in Katmai National Park. He began recording his adventures in 1999, shooting the beasts hunting salmon and mating and filming himself for hundreds of hours talking about the bears to the camera as if he were in fact taping a television show.
Treadwell's shade-wearing, sandy-haired dude persona, complete with high-pitched kid-show delivery and fierce Rousseauian idealism, is extraordinarily compelling, particularly when one of the 800-pound animals he so childishly praises creeps up behind him on camera. His post-game wrap-up after a hair-raising battle between male bears is priceless, and his genuine determination to stand off when bears get too close is mesmerizing. But it's not merely the disconnect between Treadwell's Mutual of Omaha na and the potential for feral disaster that gains momentum as Herzog's film progresses; it's clear that Treadwell, alone and self-sanctifying in the woods with only a lens to talk to, identifies more with the bears than with the society that had in effect exiled him. His way of mooning over the beasts, giving them preschool names like Mr. Chocolate and relentlessly declaring that he's "protecting" them, suggests acres about why Treadwell abandoned the company of people. Raving paranoia, against the government, tourists, would-be poachers, other activists, and anyone else in reach, seems inevitable. Meanwhile, his mission in the wilderness is persistently constructed as a Discovery Channel series, one that was never green-lit but got filmed all the same, often beautifully. Grizzly Man is many things, including a much more resonant and complex portrait of TV-poisoned narcissism than Tarnation.
For many the question remains about how Treadwell's eventual death should be regardedas a tragedy, as a fool's fate, or as comeuppance for daring to humanize wild predators and habituating them to human presence. Herzog's perspective is, of course, scrupulously nonjudgmental. He doesn't share with us the audio of the killing (in which Treadwell's girlfriend, Amie Huguenard, was also torn up and eaten), but instead grimly listens to it on camera, and then instructs a surviving ex-girlfriend to destroy the tape immediately. Mysteries, like The White Diamond's unseen waterfall caverns or the Aborigine totem that would end the world if glimpsed by a white man in Where the Green Ants Dream, are worth keeping secret.
Herzog and Treadwell occupy polar camps; fascinated though he may be by the beauty and hellfire of natural forces, Herzog is no naturalist. His career project reflects a bitterly pragmatic view of nature as ravenous, amoral, and empty-headedhardly a viewpoint sellable to cable-TV-watching schoolkids. Herzog's strong-armed interventions in Grizzly Man say as much, cutting off Treadwell's original sound in one close-up of a bear: "I must disagree with Treadwell here," he grumbles, launching into a diatribe about the essential inhumanity of wild animals. "I see only the overwhelming indifference of nature." Regarding the bears as deus ex machina within Treadwell's bizarre saga, Herzog asserts again one of modern moviedom's wisest, plainest humanistic sensibilities, sympathetic to man's never ending war with the planet but aware that the struggle will always draw ambiguous blood. Treadwell is simply another lost foot soldier, killed in the ongoing collision between human obsession and untamed reality.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!