Top

dining

Stories

 

Thanks, Cattle

On thronged Eldridge Street, maybe the best noodles of your life

Weekend afternoons—or weekdays after a van disgorges a gang of exhausted day laborers in front of the temp employment agencies down the block—the slurping can be deafening. The last block of Eldridge Street is home to Super Taste, a narrow warren specializing in hand-pulled wheat noodles, pointed out to me by Calvin Trillin. These noodles are delivered so hot, temperature-wise, that it's a matter of both good etiquette and good science to suck them down with a loud rush of cooling air. Your first exposure ought to be No. 2 on the menu. When "hand-pull noodle w. Beef in Hot & Spicy Soup" ($4) arrives, the concentrated broth is brownish red, with little drops of chile oil dancing on the surface. In the depths lurk strips of sautéed beef, baby spinach, and a generous hank of noodles. These might be the best noodles of your life.

Soup-er star
photo: Lauren Braun
Soup-er star

Though English is rarely spoken in Super Taste, the menu, like some professor of noodle history, mounts a learned and earnest discourse in English. "Lanzhou hand-pulled noodles, also known as Beef Noodles, originated from the city of Lanzhou," references a narrow metropolis, more than 20 kilometers in length, on the southern bank of the Yellow River in Inner Mongolia, where the noodles "were sold in the streets—as early as Han Dynasty and Tong Dynasty." Less romantically, a tourist guide describes the city as filthy and says it's choking on fumes. Extolling the virtues of the beef strips deposited in the soup, the professor notes optimistically: "Cattle eat [a] variety of grasses and conquer hundreds of diseases." Thank you, Elsie.

These noodles may remind you of Korean-Chinese cha chiang mein, made by slapping great wads of dough on a prep table to break down the gluten. But while the cha chiang mein fall magically into squarish strands as they're whacked, the Lanzou dough is pulled, folded over, and pulled again, till the noodles reach the desired irregular circumference. The attention to detail exhibited by the staff at Super Taste could put an Italian artisanal pastificio to shame. So careful are they, that when you ask for carryout, the noodles are put in a separate container from the broth, so as not to become mushy before being eaten.

The bargain-basement collection of a dozen dumplings ($3) is the equal of those at any of the area stalls, with the loose filling of pork and scallions encased in sheets of dough with a thickness measured in millimeters. The sweet shallot dipping sauce tastes like something a Frenchwoman might squirt on her raw oysters. Skip everything in the vermicelli section of the menu. These choices represent a parallel universe populated with pale, factory-made rice noodles that have none of the wheaten goodness of the hand-pulled. A third type, something like a Pennsylvania Dutch egg noodle dish, is featured in "peanut butter noodle" ($1.50), but this dish seems mainly directed at children and the extremely hard up.

Look around the dining room some Sunday afternoon and you'll see half the slurpers working on bowls of "hand-pull noodle w. Pork Bone in Soup," ($6). Served in a giant metal mixing bowl rather than the usual plastic receptacle and featuring six or more knuckly marrow bones with bits of meat adhering, this soup not only reunites the rich broth with the bones that generated it but gives a good folksy chew in the bargain.

 
  • John Joseph Kehoe 12/07/2011 2:04:00 AM

    I have eaten noodle in different parts of China for some time, and have found some really good noodle shops in Chinatown. This one on Eldridge St. claims to be autentic Lanzhou Pulled Noodle: 蘭州手工拉麵. In China, Lanzhou 蘭州 in Gansu Province 甘肅省 is famous for hand pulled noodles, but most of the restaurats in Chinatown NYC claming to be autentic Lanzhou hand pulled noodles are owned and operated by people from Fuzhou: 福州人. Still you can get some great taste in these shops. It should be noted that many of the hand pulled noodle shops in Lanzhou China are operated by hui 回 people, Chinese Muslims (回教) . The 26 Eldridge Street shop is not bad. Its location is nice, and it always has a few customers inside. One menu’s specialty is 岐山麵 (Mount Qi Noodle), and this is an area and mountain in 山西省 or Shanxi Province, which is quite far from northwest province of Gansu: 甘肅省. I actually ate 岐山麵 Mount Qi Noodle, and was satisfied, and highly recommend it. Spicy, with pork and mixed veggies, and nice broth. So, are the owners from Gansu 甘肅 or Shanxi山西? The owners, though I did not ask, my guess is they are : 福州人 people from Fuzhou or Fujinan, and the noodle is far from authentic Lanzhou Hand Pulled Noodle, but the noodle IS hand pulled, and the dishes are not bad. I can tell you that finding 蘭州手工拉麵 Lanzhou Hand Pulled Noodle done by a person from Lanzhou here in NYC is not going to happen, unless it is a worker form Lanzhou working for a Fujianese. None the less, hand pulled noodles in these Fuzhou owned shops can be good. If you want to eat 福州式麵 Fuzhou Style Noodle you need to go to other places and order 拌麵 Banmian (noodle w/ peanut sauce), and this is found easily at the more non-discript Fuzhou eating places for only $2. One is corner of Eldridge and Broome, another is C & L Dumpling House on Chrystie Street just up from Hester. Authentic Fujianese noodles, simple and cheap. These noodles are made fresh nightly for delivery the next day in a factory on Forsythe and Canal and sent around to the restaurants every day. The facory is near the Barbara Greek Orthodox Church, and you can walk by after midnight and see the noodles being churned out, with flour dust all through the first floor. Well, concerning eating HAND PULLED noodles ( 手工拉麵), on my last visit 26 Eldridge Street, I ordered 山西切削麵 (shanxi knife cut noodles) and though it is on the menu, they no longer offer it. My guess is they now are confined to preparing all the noodle before hand as opposed to by order. I had instead 牛肉拉麵加辣 (Beef hand pulled noodle with extra spicy). The beef slices where exceptionally geneous and very tender and delicous, the noodles fresh and good, but the broth and spice not to satisfaction. I did find their use of spice for their hot (spicy ) dishes to be under spiced. There are better places for hand pulled noodle 手工拉麵 not too far from this restaurant for about the same price $4-$7, so though I found the staff extremely nice, and friendly and helpful, it is not number on, but does have a diverse selection and delicious 岐山麵 (Mount Qi Noodle), which I recommend. And I will tell you a secret, by far the best noodles are found at a Henan 河南 Restaurant on Forsyth opposite the park up from Hester. It has both knife cut and hand pulled noodles: 切削麵 手工拉麵 都有。 The Owners ae from Henan Province河南省, the sign says Henan 河南, and the food is Henan 河南. Henan is known in China to also have great noodles. The restaurant is called 河南風味 Flavor of Henan: 68 B Forsyth St.

 

Most Popular Stories


Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy