By Jared Chausow
By Katie Toth
By Elizabeth Flock
By Albert Samaha
By Anna Merlan
By Jon Campbell
By Jon Campbell
By Albert Samaha
"Located in the center of Manhattan's chic artist enclave, the Trump International Hotel and Tower in Soho is the site of my latest development," he trumpeted, as scenes from the trendy neighborhood flashed by. "This 50-story building is the first condominium-hotel in the city, with world-class accommodations and panoramic views."
The next Manhattan behemoth to bear Trump's name looked good on-screen, a computer-generated skyscraper rising up out of the vacant lot where Trump expects the real one to stand by 2009. The project looks even better on Trump's websiteyes, trump.com which pans from the top to the bottom of a tall, glittery tower, as smooth jazz plays in the background.
But in real life, things don't seem quite so smooth. Over the past two months, a ground war has begun against Trump and his developer partners, with preservationists, residents, and business advocates saying the proposal amounts to an apartment tower that merely masquerades as a hotel. They're convinced it violates the area's zoning code, which allows industrial and commercial outlets, not residences. Trump may rule on television, but in Gotham he's fighting a grassroots campaign of letter writing and phone calls to city officials. And he may be losing. On July 13, the resisters won backing from a Community Board 2 subcommittee, which rejected the plan unanimously.
"He is using this as a Trojan horse to build residences," charges Sean Sweeney, of the Soho Alliance, referring to the Donald, of course. "He's going around the zoning here. It's typical Trump arrogance."
Trump and his partners insist the Soho tower is a hotel, and of the five-star variety, to boot; it will offer 24-hour room service and housekeeping, a rooftop pool, and a day spa. Julius Schwarz, of the Bayrock Group, the project's managing partner, says the only difference between this place and any other "ultra-luxury" hotel is that people will be able to buy one of the 415 units. Geared to the wealthy thirtysomething crowd, the suites will be sold individually as pieds-à-terre. The usually absent owners will rent out their units as hotel rooms and pocket the money. "There is no residential use involved in this project," Schwarz says.
His famous partner didn't get ahead of himself by announcing the project on TV, Schwarz says. He says they can build the condo-hotel under the zoning code, "as of right."
The winning apprentice will have for a boss Donald Trump Jr., who's managing the overall project with his father and sister, Ivanka. "We knew back on June 5 that we had the right to build Trump Soho," Trump Jr. tells the Voice in a brief e-mail. "There was no community reaction to the hotel at the time, so we were not cautious about announcing this exciting project."
Trump has never been known for caution. Brash, ambitious, filthy rich: These words define the 60-year-old property mogul. In 2001, he faced down the fury of luminaries like Walter Cronkite and Kofi Annan, who happened to live near his planned 90-story Trump World Towerthe tallest residential tower on earth.
No celebrities are lending their names to this latest fight, at least not yet. Contrary to Trump's dramatic description on The Apprentice, 246 Spring is a parking lot on the outskirts of Soho, at the corner of Varick Street, just blocks from the Holland Tunnel, in an outpost of old factory buildings turned design offices, printing firms, and storage facilities.
"This area has always housed classic light industry," says Andrew Berman, director of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation and leading fly in Trump's ointment. Now, he says, the neighborhood is undergoing a classic phenomenonthe one of "the big-name developer bending the rules to get what he wants."
Berman says his first reaction to the Trump project was to be horrified at the scale, which will rival that of skyscrapers on Wall Street. (The building will actually stand 42 stories tall, according to Schwarz.) He reached out to the manufacturers, who saw their own interests at stake. Adam Friedman, of the New York Industrial Retention Network, which represents 400 or so manufacturers citywide, says the building would have a ripple effect. Whenever the city has OK'd residential uses in industrial zones, Friedman says, manufacturers have been forced out. If the city grants Trump his permits, he argues, it'll pave the way for high-rise residential buildings in industrial zones citywide, from Red Hook to Long Island City. "This hotel really isn't a hotel," he says. "It's camouflage or subterfuge for residential development."
Trump and company deny bending any zoning rules. They insist their condo-hotel is designed solely for short-term stays. Sure, people will buy units to live in. No matter. "We are absolutely complying with the building regulations," Schwarz says. Condo owners won't be allowed to remain in their places for more than 29 consecutive days, for instance, as is the case in standard hotels. To satisfy zoning, he says, they've eliminated some original amenities, such as stovetops in the kitchenettes.