Boy Soldier of Fortune

"Look at any map of Sierra Leone and you'll see the inaccuracy," he said. "The book version is five times larger than any other version I've seen." Beah's publishers at FSG insist that the map is accurate. But officials with HarperCollins told Wilson that they plan on correcting the map in future editions. London journalist Bryan Appleyard has written that the map is "the grossest error I have ever seen in a book from a major publishing house."

Another odd circumstance, Harayda noted, is that Beah's book and a novel about the civil war published in 2005 both contain soldiers who recite and perform Shakespeare.The novel, Moses, Citizen and Me, was published prior to Beah's book. The Voice contacted author Delia Jarrett Macaulay via her publisher but didn't receive a response.

Stacy Kranitz

Columbia University professor Neil Boothby has examined enough child-soldier tales to question Beah’s.

Related Content

• What's Happening This Week: World Water Week, Pizza Lessons
  March 19, 2012
• Hollywood's 10 Highest Paid Actresses
  July 7, 2011
• 'Concert for Bangladesh Revisited'
  November 9, 2011
• 'George Harrison's All Things Must Pass 40th Anniversary Benefit Concert'
  November 17, 2010
• Top Chef Alums Rally to Raise Money for Japan
  April 5, 2011

More About

• Ishmael Beah
• Peter Wilson
• UNICEF
• Books and Literature
• Arts, Entertainment, and Media

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Weekly Newsletter: (Sent out every Thursday) Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.

Privacy Policy Cancel Continue

"It seems to me that Beah's book has gotten much less scrutiny than it deserved," Harayda said. "People think if you question the book, you're questioning whether child soldiering is a tragedy. They are separate issues."

But St. John, the Portland professor, said Beah's story is so powerful that he's willing to give the author the benefit of the doubt. "Hell is hell, no matter how long you were in it," he said.

For the reporters from The Australian, however, the course that the story has followed remains mystifying. "We have had no agenda, and we have wondered about the motivation of Beah's supporters," Nason said. "My view is they are clinging to Beah's futile protestations of truth and accuracy to protect themselves . . . . But nobody will let us near Beah to try and find out."