Top

news

Stories

 

Don't Buy the New Welfare-Queen Myth

Dear Mexican: As a Mexican, I'm always ashamed of the fact that a lot of Mexican women come to the U.S. just to have babies and utilize this country's welfare system. I know a lot of them that just keep having children and don't pay a dollar for the hospital care. They even lie about their marital status so they can get all the benefits without having earned them! But my question is this: Am I culero to feel that way? Do I betray my Mexican sisters because I think that if they can't support a family on their own, they should not propagate at our system's expense? Many of the people I know have had more than one baby! —Soy Culero

Dear I'm an Asshole: What's a fact? That some illegal immigrants have children in this country? Duh. But to claim that said people live it up by popping out more niños is a myth as fanciful as Reagan's welfare queen, unless your idea of paradise is waiting for the sword of Damocles called la migra. You're right in despising women who love spreading their legs yet can't pay for the resultant kiddies or even a pinche condom—but don't buy the hype that the vast majority of so-called "anchor babies" (also known as "United States citizens by virtue of the Constitution as upheld by the Supreme Court") were born with the explicit intent of enriching their parents. There's a lot of anecdotal evidence regarding such Mexicans (shit, I know a couple such putas), but the Mexican has never seen any empirical evidence documenting that this is a phenomenon on the level of salsa being America's top-selling condiment. Besides, illegal immigrants don't qualify for most social-assistance programs—only their children do, and those children are Americans, and it's OK for Americans to use welfare per the Manichean arguments of anti-immigrant loons, so what's the problem?

Dear Mexican: When I drive through my culturally diverse 'hood, I can spot the Mexicans. Even in August in San Antonio, the garage door is up, the interior garage walls are painted some garish blue or yellow, the television is blaring some game, and a crowd of Mexicans are sitting in lawn chairs and swilling beer from the garage refrigerator. Since when did the room where you should park your cars become a social habitat for Mexicans? Why do Mexicans like to sit in their garages, in the sweltering heat, and think that they're having a great time? —White Boy With a Squeaky-Clean Lexus IN the Garage

Dear Gabacho: Broder, you just described it. Whereas gabachos see a garage as a place to store their junk, cars, and meth labs, Mexicans see endless possibilities. A lounge. Workplace. Abattoir. An extra room to rent out to a couple dozen strangers. Everything, really, except a parking spot—that's what the lawn's for.

SHAMELESS SELF-PROMOTION ALERT! Got a new book coming out in a month,cabronesOrange County: A Personal History, my memoir of the most-Mexican-hating region in the Republic and the Reconquista. Learn theshocking truth about Mexicans learning English, attending college, and becoming more American than nachos! Check this column for future invasion dates in your town!

 
  • Ty Garrett 08/19/2008 5:25:00 AM

    Regarding the August 12, 2008 Ask A Mexican submission entitled "Baby's Aweigh, Don't Buy The New Welfare Queen Myth": Being a non-white minority (American-born), I understand the need to discredit negative stereotypes and misconceptions of one's culture or origin, but your superficially lame and pathetically disingenuous response enlightened me to the obvious mindset that many people use to justify giving birth to multiple children while living unlawfully in a foreign nation. Though you acknowledge that some illegal immigrants have children in this country (Duh), you state that it is a myth...that the majority of "anchor babies"...were born with the explicit intent of enriching their parents. You also say that these AMERICAN (emphasis mine) children qualify for most social welfare programs, not their parents. But pregnant women, regardless of immigration status are not denied medical care, and though this is a good thing, it does enrich the parents. And if these children receive social welfare benefits as rights guaranteed to American citizens, then the parents that live under the roofs paid for by social welfare funds, and eat food courtesy of the children's benefits are similarly enriched. And your justification is that is is OK for Americans to use welfare. You further discredit the idea because you have never seen any empirical evidence...well I haven't seen any evidence to the contrary. You are a sad representative for your countrymen, and your words are an insult to hard-working Americans.

  • Ty Garrett 08/19/2008 5:23:00 AM

    Regarding the August 12, 2008 Ask A Mexican submission entitled "Baby's Aweigh, Don't Buy The New Welfare Queen Myth": Being a non-white minority (American-born), I understand the need to discredit negative stereotypes and misconceptions of one's culture or origin, but your superficially lame and pathetically disingenuous response enlightened me to the obvious mindset that many people use to justify giving birth to multiple children while living unlawfully in a foreign nation. Though you acknowledge that some illegal immigrants have children in this country (Duh), you state that it is a myth...that the majority of "anchor babies"...were born with the explicit intent of enriching their parents. You also say that these AMERICAN (emphasis mine) children qualify for most social welfare programs, not their parents. But pregnant women, regardless of immigration status are not denied medical care, and though this is a good thing, it does enrich the parents. And if these children receive social welfare benefits as rights guaranteed to American citizens, then the parents that live under the roofs paid for by social welfare funds, and eat food courtesy of the children's benefits are similarly enriched. And your justification is that is is OK for Americans to use welfare. You further discredit the idea because you have never seen any empirical evidence...well I haven't seen any evidence to the contrary. You are a sad representative for your countrymen, and your words are an insult to hard-working Americans.

 

Most Popular Stories


Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy