By Pete Kotz
By Michael Musto
By Michael Musto
By Capt. James Van Thach told to Jonathan Wei
By Kera Bolonik
By Michael Musto
By Nick Pinto
By Steve Weinstein
Some 400,000 Americans die every year from smoking, and if you want the grim details of how this killing ground came to be, you might ask New York's newest senator. Before she went into politics to make people's lives better, Kirsten Gillibrand had a first-class education in how the cigarette industry tears them apart.
The lessons came as an eager young associate at the big law firm of Davis, Polk & Wardwell on Lexington Avenue. She started there in 1991, age 25. Her employers promptly placed her on the front lines on behalf of its hugely important client, Philip Morris, Inc. The tobacco giant was battling criminal and civil lawsuits accusing it of luring generations of smokers into death and disease, and it had enlisted vast numbers of lawyers in its defense. By all accounts, Gillibrand—then still the unmarried Kirsten Rutnik—was one of the most able and hardworking. Over the next nine years, before she moved on in the spring of 2000, the tobacco world and its tangled nasty secrets were a large part of her life.
Gillibrand has said since, and maintains today, that as a lowly associate, she had no say in this assignment, that she was pressed into duty and simply gave it her lawyerly best. "You don't get to choose as a young attorney," said spokeswoman Rachel McEneny last week. Well, had she ever, in all of those nine years, asked off the dreaded tobacco case?
"Good question," said McEneny. "I'll check." The answer came a few hours later: "No."
Maybe that's because tobacco is where the action was. Voluminous records pried loose through multiple lawsuits show that during Rutnik's assignment, she debriefed tobacco's top engineers on everything they did to keep cigarettes in the hands of millions. She spent hours with those who fashioned the filters that were supposed to screen out the harshest elements, but which still let smokers suck toxic doses into their lungs.
The firm sent her to Europe at least four times. There, she toured laboratories that the company maintained in Belgium, Switzerland, and Germany in order to keep the disturbing results of their biological studies out of the hands of American courts and the public. Most infamous of these was INBIFO—Institut fur Biologische Forschung—in Cologne, where scientists experimented on the toxicology of tobacco.
How secret was this place? "They wouldn't even let me go there," says William Farone, who spent seven years as director of applied research at Philip Morris's Richmond, Virginia, base in the 1970s and '80s. "That was where all the carcinogenic testing was being done on animals," says Farone. "They didn't want those records subpoenaed. In the U.S., they're denying smoking causes cancer; in Europe, they're proving that it does."
In January 1996, five years after she was drafted into big tobacco's campaign, Kirsten Rutnik scheduled two full days of interviews at INBIFO, records show, including a four-hour session with director Dr. Wolf Reininghaus, author of such works as "90-Day Inhalation Study" and "Tumor Formation on Rats." She was back that summer for more meetings, and visited again in 1997 and 1998. Her work on the research facility was hefty enough to constitute an entire binder that sat on the shelf of Charles R. Wall, Philip Morris's general counsel and supreme commander of the army of lawyers trying to hold back the tide.
Gillibrand's handlers insist that her tobacco-defense work is old news. The issue was put to rest last year, says spokeswoman McEneny, when her Republican opponent failed to score with voters, even after he outspent her nearly two to one, running TV attack ads on the subject and dispatching reams of documents to reporters. Indeed, if you look at a debate clip of GOP candidate Sandy Treadwell accusing Gillibrand of running secret missions for her client in Germany, you can see Gillibrand's mouth curl slowly into a smile and then burst into laughter. Ho, ho, ho. Even after the Albany Times Union's excellent James Odato wrote a detailed story about her role, Gillibrand batted the issue aside. She claimed to the Times Union's editorial board that her job was nothing more than "sitting in conference rooms going through subpoenaed documents."
Actually, Gillibrand could have legitimately put her tobacco ties into the political rearview mirror had she simply said that, as a public official, she wanted nothing more to do with the industry or its money. But contributions from Philip Morris—since renamed "Altria"—and her tobacco co-workers at Davis, Polk & Wardwell have swelled her campaign war chest, so far with more than $150,000. "When you start out in fundraising, you reach out to the people you had relationships with," explains McEneny.
Has she ever considered not taking tobacco money? "No," says the spokeswoman after a pause.
That's an interesting decision for someone who spent almost a decade rooting about in smoking's secret cellars. "Given what she must have learned about the activities of the tobacco industry as their lawyer, you would think it would make it hard for her to take their campaign contributions in her new role as a member of Congress," says Russell Sciandra, the American Cancer Society's Albany representative.
Find everything you're looking for in your city
Find the best happy hour deals in your city
Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%
Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city