Top

news

Stories

 

Guantanamo's Final Days

The infamous Prison Camp ain't dead yet

In 1992, Ahmed stepped on a land mine and was injured so badly he was evacuated to Toronto. For a time, the family lived off donations from area mosques, eventually squeezing into a humble flat in a rundown rooming house on the city's west end.

Omar was still in many ways a regular kid. He loved Nintendo, the Bruce Willis movie Die Hard, and junk food. He played basketball and cricket in an alley with his brothers and friends from the local mosque.

Soldier Morris
Courtesy Layne Morris
Soldier Morris
The hastily built rooms at Camp X-Ray
Barry Blend
The hastily built rooms at Camp X-Ray

By 1993, Ahmed had healed sufficiently to return with his family to Pakistan. Not long after arriving, he allegedly began plotting with Ayman al-Zawahiri, Osama bin Laden's right-hand man, to blow up the Egyptian embassy. The November 19, 1995, bombing killed 16 and wounded 60. Ahmed was arrested and sent to prison. He went on a hunger strike, protesting his innocence, and was transferred to a hospital in Islamabad. Omar, who was nine years old at the time, didn't leave his father's side, often sleeping under the man's bed on the concrete floor.

But the Canadian government lobbied for Ahmed's release, and soon the family was living in Afghanistan with Osama bin Laden. Not yet 12 years old, Omar joined two of his older brothers at an Al-Qaeda training camp, where they were taught to fire Kalashnikovs and build bombs. "[We learned] why we are fighting America . . . why being a suicide bomber is an honor, why it's a right religiously," Omar's brother, Abdurahman, told CNN.

The Pentagon claims to have surveillance video that shows Omar planting a bomb on a road frequently traveled by U.S. troops. "That kid became radicalized," says Khadr's former imam. "It's impossible to go through the experiences he went through and not be affected by them."

When Khadr was captured in the July 2002 firefight that wounded Layne Morris, he was near death. Medics rushed him to the Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan, and a few months later, he was dressed in an orange jumpsuit, hogtied, and placed on a C-130 transport headed for Guantánamo.


The Bush administration began using the base at Guantánamo Bay as a modern-day gulag in January 2002, just four months after the Twin Towers fell in New York. The first camp, called X-Ray for its coordinates on a military map, is now in decay, surrounded by razor wire. It sits in a remote, low-lying valley, a rusting ring of cages covered with weeds and vines.

"I would bet my boots that when the American public thinks of Guantánamo, they think of these pumped-up Taliban warriors," says Khadr's lawyer, Canadian Dennis Edney. "In reality, in the first few years Omar was there, it was a house of horrors. It was a place where Omar was taken from death and back."

Omar Khadr's arrival at Guantánamo in October 2002 coincided with a fundamental shift in the War on Terror. In the 10 months the camp had been open to "unlawful enemy combatants," the military had learned little about Al-Qaeda's inner workings. So officers began employing techniques that included sensory deprivation, waterboarding, and degrading humiliation.

Shortly after his arrival, Khadr was taken to an interrogation room, where his arms were pulled behind his back and cuffed to his legs, straining his sockets until he was near delirium, according to the boy's sworn affidavit. He claims he was then forced onto his knees with his wrists cuffed to his ankles. This lasted so long that the 16-year-old urinated on himself. When the military police returned, he contends, they doused him with Pine-Sol and used him as a human mop to clean up the mess. He was then carried back to his cell, where he was left for two days.

Despite these tactics, little intelligence came from the prison camp, CIA sources told author Jane Mayer for her 2008 book, The Dark Side. So the CIA sent an intelligence analyst to Guantánamo. He interviewed about two dozen detainees and concluded about a third of the camp's population had no connection to terrorism.

Mahvish Khan, then a University of Miami law student, found something similar when she began visiting the camp as a translator. The child of Afghan immigrant parents who had gone on to become doctors, she had grown up in a conservative Muslim home in Michigan.

Khan says she expected to find members of the Taliban or Al-Qaeda. Instead, the first detainee she met was a pediatrician who had worked to establish democracy in Afghanistan and then fled to Syria when the Taliban took over. The second man was an 80-year-old paraplegic who had been bedridden for 15 years. Bounty hunters had delivered both of them. "Most of the people were there because they were turned in for money or because there was some sort of tribal feud," she says.

In summer 2004, two years after Khadr's arrival, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the Bush administration could not hold prisoners indefinitely without charges. Detainees had the right to try their cases in federal court. In response, camp authorities quietly released 114 detainees by the end of the year. Virtually none had seen the evidence against them. In June 2006, the Supreme Court suspended the tribunals for three months until Congress officially authorized them.

<< Previous Page | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next Page >>
 
  • Marnie Tunay 05/27/2009 8:17:00 AM

    It's not true that Dennis Edney wants Omar Khadr to move in with him. In fact he said the opposite when I had coffee with him in early November, 2009. Marnie Tunay Fakirs Canada http://fakirscanada.spaces.live.com/default.aspx

  • Maureen Santora 03/18/2009 7:22:00 AM

    When a person young or otherwise decides to purposely harm another human being, he should be made accountable for his actions. We have forgotten the almost 3,000 individuals who died on September 11, 2001. We have forgotten the soldiers who have died and the ones who are injured like soldier Morris. Why have the terrorists and the detainees who were arrested because of war crimes now the victims? The soldiers at Guantanamo are professional and doing a job that most of us could not do. My husband and I were privleged to meet them personally when we went to the trials in late November 2008. These terrorists are proud to have harmed America. They have no intention to change their views and be "assimilated" into western society. If given the opportunity they have vowed to strike again. What is wrong with the public and the press that their intentions are not clearly understood. They will not rest until we are defeated. We must make every attempt to protect ourselves. If that means incarcaration for the many detainees than so be it. We must stop feeling sorry for these individuals who are proud and happy that they have killed our citizens.

  • Mike 03/07/2009 7:37:00 PM

    Guantanamo was a terrible mistake. Locking people up indefinitely without a fair and speedy trial is the ultimate un-American activity. It is a cop-out to use the fear card and say that we'll lock them up "just in case". I am in the military and spent time in Afghanistan and sympathize with the difficulty of telling the good guys from the bad guys. Cops face this dilemma everyday. That is why we have a separate judiciary to weight the evidence against an individual in a setting where both the prosecution and the defense have access to both the individual and the evidence. Locking people up based on classified information is a huge no-no. That person can never receive a fair trial. There are no easy answers or perfect solutions in real life. Guantanamo was too easy and we will be paying the price for this travesty of justice for years to come. It only gives the radical recruiters more talking points.

  • Joanne Pacicca 03/01/2009 1:36:00 AM

    Jeff you are certainly right...and logical! Great post!

  • Jeffrey Saxton 03/01/2009 12:11:00 AM

    Sorry for the typo...Thanks Tim Elfrink!

  • Jeff Saxton 02/28/2009 11:48:00 PM

    Joanne, Stan's statements can't be "traitorist" because he's Canadian and ridiculing Canada doesn't solve anything. Gitmo's use to warehouse and torture "prisoners of war" was wrong, but the wholesale release of these threats isn't right either. One possible solution is to take the Taliban up on their desire for a truce, as long as they do not harbor or provide support for al-Qaeda. Relying on rehabilitation alone will be difficult, since after undergoing torture the prisoners would naturally be more radicalized. The irony of this "War on Terrorism" is how we have unwittingly helped the recruitment of thousands of willing volunteers into al-Qaeda and radical Islam by shrub's agression into Iraq. And for every innocent civilian killed by our troops in Afganistan or by a Hellfire missle launched by a Predator into Pakistan, we play into our enemy's hand, helping to provide willing foot-soldiers in their fight against our troops and the US and it's allies in general (which President Obama has embraced, considering the present frequency of these illogical and illegal attacks into Pakistan). The ultimate irony is that killing bin-Laden and/or his lieutenants will not help stop the killing of Americans. Since al-Qaeda is divided into autonomous cells, killing him will simply turn bin-Laden into a martyr. Not to say he shouldn't be brought to justice, but our efforts to eradicate al-Qaeda should be applied like a surgeon's skill world-wide and not be viewed with the tunnel vision view that killing bin-Laden is going to end the threat to our country. I don't have an answer on what we should do with Kadr and other's of his ilk, but simply letting them go is not the answer. I would like to thank Tim Elfink and Jesse Hyde for a fair and balanced bit of reporting and the Village Voice for publishing it.

  • Joanne Pacicca 02/27/2009 5:48:00 AM

    Of course, the mistakes of the past must be corrected with solutions that protect our military and citizenship. The issue of Guantanamo is a shame...for those that constructed and supported it. However, I do not agree with the traitorist comments above. There must be rules and the Geneva Convention should be evoked by the USA. By the way, Canada is "America Light".

  • stan squires 02/25/2009 9:30:00 PM

    I wanted to say that Omar Khadr shouldn't have been in Guantanamo to begin with.He should be here in canada.Those people who are slandering him should be behind bars.The real terrorists are the american gov.who supported the taliban in the 1980s and gave them arms and anything else they wanted.The canadian gov. is no better for having troops in Afghanstan.Omar Khadr is an innocent person and there is lots of evidence to back that up.There is no one at Guantanamo that can get a fair trial.The quicker that place is closed down the better. Stan squires

 

Most Popular Stories


Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy