10% Off Purchase
New York, NY 10003
Bella: Im coming.
Edward: I dont want you to.
The Twilight Saga: New Moon
Worry not for the purity of your tween girls, global mothers. Where Catherine Hardwickes lively, irreverent take on the first book in the Twilight series at least made room for a few suggestive winks, the sequel is stuck right in the abstinence mud with author Stephenie Meyer. Meyer may be, as Oprah admiringly called her recently, a black-belt reader, but as a writer, shes strictly Dear Diary, and Melissa Rosenberg, who wrote The Twilight Saga: New Moon, is nothing if not respectful of her vapid prose. The movie, directed by Chris Weitz, comes off very much like Clint Eastwoods The Bridges of Madison Countyprofessional filmmaking applied to sub-literary euphemistic trash, in this case couched in the jejune crush-fantasies of a Mormon mom stranded at home with three little boys. Personally, I dont get the lure of vampire chic, but attention must be paid, if only because millions of girls on the cusp of adolescence and beyondnot to mention, after lights out, their mothersgroove to Meyers chaste, oddly bloodless, and nearly plotless saga of a troubled high school outsider who finds love and protection with a family of expensively attired bloodsuckers in red-gold contact lenses.
If nothing else, the new movie honors the anodyne spirit of its sourcegive or take a few CGI face-offs between werewolves and vampires. New moon or not, Bella (Kristen Stewart) is still yearning on, and on and on and on, for the neck bite that will be her ticket to eternal supernatural bliss with Edward (Robert Pattinson), he of the moussed hair, fairy-dusted skin, and no personality to speak of.
All media reports to the contrary, Edward has not left the building. After a very long goodbye, repeated at 15-minute intervals with mournful stares and fluttery mini-kisses, he mysteriously retreats briefly to vampire country, then returns in ghostly form to protect Bella from . . . nothing very much, unless you count the more than three months, unfolding in what feels like real-time, that she spends pining away in bed. Some day, Kristen Stewart, who cut a striking presence earlier this year in Greg Mottolas Adventureland, will do great things with her instinctive intensity, but as Bella, she stares and mutters, mutters and stares until, discovering risky behavior a la Church of Latter-Day Saints, she hitches a 100-yard motorbike ride with a complete stranger, then settles for bike assembly with good old reliable schoolmate Jacob (Taylor Lautner), who is not all he seems.
A moment of carnal potential rears its head briefly when Lautner, pumped unto incredible hulk, strips off his shirt, eliciting girlish screams from the audience that even the subsequent display of Pattinsons puny white torso cant measure up to. Weitz, who seems to have dozed through the making of New Moon thus far, wakes up long enough to deliver a short display of bare-fanged competitive masculinity, followed by a sudden trip to something resembling Italy, with lots of red robes (thank you, Dan Brown) and over-the-top Catholicity. There, in a movie almost totally devoid of humor, let alone real passion, waits Michael Sheen, king of the evil Volturi, decked out in a long, black wig and a curling lip. Alone of all the earnest players in this turgidly euphemistic melodrama, Sheen seems to grasp that the only way you can keep a straight face through this choked-up virginity is to carry it way into camp.
"...since abstinence is a major tenet of Meyer's books, and of the movies, and a central tenet of Mormonism, I could hardly get by without making the connection..." Actually, Ms Taylor, the connection between Twilight�s celibacy and Mormon pre-marital abstinence is very superficial. Edward and Bella don�t have any serious ethical or theological commitment to chastity��indeed, their virginity is almost an accident. In the novels, both characters at various points are ready to let the deflowering commence, but they just never happen to be in sync; when she�s ready, he�s reticent, and vice-versa. Nevertheless, as the series continues, the lovebirds are engaged in nearly perpetual, semi-clothed make-out. Their (breathless, overlong) courtship finally culminates in a wedding and a tropical honeymoon, complete with beach house, shredded pillows, broken headboards, and plenty of rough sex, leaving our heroine with creaky joints and lots of bruises (and��*spoiler*��pregnant with devil-spawn that practically claws its way out of her uterus a few weeks later, kinda like John Hurt in Alien... or, more precisely, like the alien in John Hurt). That having been said, there ARE actually some uniquely Mormon themes in the books, but they�re not what you might guess. The lack of pre-marital sex here is only �Mormon� in the sense that, lacking explicit material, LDS parents are willing to buy the books for their LDS daughters (their sons probably buy their own copies... VERY discreetly), because the books are written by an LDS author, and used to be sold at LDS bookstores. (Incidentally, a couple months back, Deseret Book stopped stocking the Twilight series, due to the fact that��while they don�t depict illicit sex��some parents still thought they were a bit too erotic.) In any case, Edward and Bella�s relationship (particularly its physical aspect) isn�t any more grounded in the Mormon moral universe than Romeo and Juliet�s.
Great review, except for the assertion that authors of Young Adult literature need to create Gossip Girl-esque plot lines to be worthy of anything. I brought a car-ful of 8th grade students to see the movie today and was proud that I could do so without feeling embarrassed about its content. I'm glad that both Stephenie Meyer and the film's directors left something to the imagination...for once. It would have been easy to throw a sex scene in there and bring in couple more million from boys young and old.
Well, this review is a little unclear. I think you don't know the half of what your saying. Hmm... I want reviews that are solid, and true. Not reviews that are just a bunch of lies and things that just want some views. Jessica Baxster is the best critic I know. You just make this review unreal and amusing. This is like watching new moon all over again.
Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...
Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...
More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience
Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info
Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips
Log in or Sign up
Social Connect:Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.
Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:
Sign Up or Log in
Social Connect:Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.
Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:
