Top

film

Stories

 

Better to Look Good than Be Good for Tom Ford's A Single Man

Too much is never enough for fashion designer turned filmmaker Tom Ford, whose debut feature flaunts its capital-A Artiness the way some Napoleonic gym rats flaunt their overdeveloped musculature. Unlike his fellow art-house Michael BaysJulie Taymor, Julian Schnabel, and Baz Luhrmann—Ford doesn't whip his camera into dizzying blurs, chop his scenes into abstract fricassées, or subject us to elaborate acid-flashback fantasy sequences; he does, however, share their affection for art direction over actual direction, and for extravagant surfaces over the lower depths of meaning and emotion. Based on Christopher Isherwood's 1964 novel, Ford's A Single Man is nothing if not a master class in sartorial excellence ("Wardrobe for Colin Firth Provided by Tom Ford Menswear" state the credits), freshly exfoliated skin, and modern Southern California architecture. Not a hair or a shaft of light appears out of its careful place. Think of it as Vogue Hommes: The Movie.

Are you sure I shouldn't wear a vest, Tom?
Eduard Grau
Are you sure I shouldn't wear a vest, Tom?

Ford, who also co-wrote the screenplay, hews fairly close to the events of Isherwood's slender, elegant novel—one of his best—which encompasses a day in the life of George Falconer (played in the movie by Firth), a British ex-pat teaching English at a small Los Angeles college around the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis and, when the story begins, mourning the recent death of his longtime lover and companion, Jim. Over the course of George's day, he endures the casual homophobia of his smiling suburban neighbors, lectures on Aldous Huxley to a classroom of complacent, disinterested students, and drops in for dinner with his big-haired, gin-swilling divorcée confidante (Julianne Moore), all the while pondering his station in life and what—if anything—our brief time on this earth really means. Eventually, the prof ends up drowning his sorrows at a local watering hole, where he happens upon his fair-haired, flirtatious student, Kenny (Nicholas Hoult), who challenges him to a late-night skinny dip in the Pacific and subsequently follows him home, perhaps not just to towel off.

Ford, who discovered Isherwood's novel when he was in his early 20s, has said he was "moved by the honesty and simplicity of the story." Simplicity, however, is not his strong suit on the big screen any more than it was on the fashion runway (where, after one 2000 show, the London Independent credited him with "adding the porn-star look to Milan's increasingly flamboyant portfolio"). Gussied up with enough stylistic fireworks for several Fourth of July parades, A Single Man lets you know what you're in for early on, with a tedious opening-credits sequence set over a nude Firth writhing about in a bottomless sea (a ploddingly literal interpretation of a metaphor from the novel's final pages), followed by an equally protracted montage of George going through his daily grooming rituals—a practical primer in how to be Mr. Ford, minus the impeccably cultivated five o'clock shadow.

No more than 10 minutes in, the movie already has the feel of an exquisitely preserved corpse laid out for viewing, which may be partly intentional given that the director has also decided to amplify Isherwood's melancholic tone by turning George from a mild depressive into a full-blown suicide case. But his greatest concession to Style (and to sheer folly) comes in the form of the desaturated color palate he concocts together with his cinematographer, Eduard Grau—a funereal succession of blacks, grays, and browns that periodically erupts into full-blown Technicolor whenever George feels a flush of passion and an accompanying rush of blood to his lower extremities. One can think of any number of actual porn films with a less obvious touch and more genuine feeling.

Along the way, Ford doffs his hat to such fellow cine-maximalists as Antonioni, Wong Kar-wai (whose In the Mood For Love composer, Shigeru Umebayashi, shares credit for the movie's thunderous, pseudo–Philip Glass score), and Alfred Hitchcock (a building-size Psycho poster looming like a sentry over George's brief encounter with a Spanish hustler in a liquor-store parking lot), which only serves to underscore those filmmakers' innate ability to transfigure style into content, artifice into art. Whereas Todd Haynes, a semiotician by training, used the carefully manicured 1950s hedgerows of Far From Heaven—another obvious influence—as a window in to the era's pervasive psychosexual repression, A Single Man, with one significant exception, gives us only a series of immaculate poses.

The exception is Firth, who, in spite of Ford's best efforts to turn him, too, into another piece of movable scenery, manages to convey a real human soul stirring beneath George's petrified façade—the sense of a vulnerable man, fundamentally uncomfortable in his own skin, who has lost the only person who ever allowed him to lose sight of himself. His performance is an island of honesty and simplicity, swallowed up by a sea of excess.

 
  • Graham Alex 03/06/2010 3:17:00 PM

    I saw the film today. I was apprehensive given all the hype. I had read all of Isherwood's works in my university days. ASM was one of my favourites. The film, while beautifully styled, was very heavy handed and predictable in its delivery. This review and several others which are picking up on some of he weaknesses, reassured me that I was right in feeling how I did upon leaving the cinema. I felt completely devoid of any feeling. And let me tell you, I am passionate about films and literature (I have taught both - for nearly 30 years). While Colin Firth delivers a fine performance, and I for one would love to see him have an Oscar awarded to him (more for his previous work, and no, he has been in more than just Love Actually and Bridget Jones), I could feel him trying to rise abaove the restraints of an over-stylised production. Interestingly, my partner, who is a stylist and worked in the Luxury market for 30 years, adored it! I rest my case. This is a beautifully presented film, but it is not a work of art. I really find it annoying that Tom Ford, whom I respect and admired, has hijacked this story and lived vicariously though his rendering of the film (ie. George's suit by Tom Ford Menswear, which is just one example). The whole film needed to be roughed up or "dirtied", it needs more textures and light and shade and it needs to be more like real, not a 2009 reinterpetation. As well, George is meant to be 58 not 52 and this makes a huge difference! A good film, but it missed he mark and it could have been so great!

  • Ray 02/18/2010 10:45:00 PM

    Spot-on review, Mr. Foundas. I was afraid I was alone in my critcisms of the film, which echo yours exactly. The film looks great, sounds great, but was exceptionally shallow.

  • B edward 02/05/2010 9:48:00 AM

    I loved - ok, well, enjoyed - the movie. My boyfriend, not so much. So I turned to Rotten Tomatoes to see the critical consensus, knowing it would be mostly in my favor. Still, I thought my boyfriend's criticisms of the movie were valid: that it was boring and shallow. I liked the style and pace of the movie, not really caring that much about the emotional content, or lackthereof. I decided to read the critical reviews, and have found them perfectly reasonable. So yes, the critics who hated the movie are correct in their criticism. Still, I enjoyed the movie, including the brief glimpses of pretty male buttocks. Perhaps I am simply getting shallower as I age.

  • Linda N Ross 01/31/2010 10:37:00 PM

    Silly really, but what happened to the second dog? One dog died in the car accident, as reported by the phone call to George. The second dog, anyone?

  • Michael O'Farrell 01/30/2010 4:31:00 AM

    I don't agree with Mr. Foundas. Write all you want about the artifice and shallowness of Tom Ford's debut feature but I found this film deeply moving. Yes, the film looks terrific. The cinematography, costumes, art direction, music score, sound and film editing are well nigh perfect. That is not at all unusual in this day and age : there are many movies that could be termed pretty, even beautiful. But Tom Ford seems to be a born filmmaker and the bottom line is that he succeeds (for this viewer, anyway) in bringing Christopher Isherwood's brilliant novel to the screen with the story intact and the character of George Falconer brought brilliantly to life by Colin Firth. A Single Man certainly deserves to be seen. It is one of the best films of the year.

  • Daniel 01/28/2010 10:56:00 AM

    Thank God for one perceptive, non-retarded review of this ludicrous piece of shallow hokum. Having a none=-too-bright fashion designer like Ford film a great Isherwood novel is like having Mel Gibson film William Shakesspeare. Oh wait, Gibson once did film "Hamlet," and wasn't too dreadful. OK. But let us forget about the novel. I loved it, but barely remember it's details 35 years later. What I cannot forget is how cliched, simplistic, and hilariously shallow this perfume ad turned movie is. Every college student is a gorgeous model, and our small-time college prof lives like a Californian rajah, with his pick of the most beautiful boys in the western world anytime he ventures out of his millionaire's play-pen of a home. Everything scene, except the bar scene where our hero meets his great love, lacks the feel, texture and sounds of real life. And yet for all the pretty visuals, there is no sense of true dreaminess, or any imagistic cogency. It's visual flair that isn't even skin deep. And Moore as the fag-hag cliche is barely two-dimensional. I never believed he was a man contemplating suicide, nor one choosing to reverse his doomy desision. When fashion designers decide to make "deep" movies about love, life and death, should we be surprised when their lovely little cinematic fashion spreads are dead on arrival? But why the critical raves? I assume the movie critics are aftraid to criticize one of the very few overtly gay mainstream films, because if this movie was about a heterosexual it would have been laughed out of town.

  • janet miller 01/20/2010 12:57:00 PM

    well, i Want to see the film three times. never having read the book meant no quibbles about the plot, nothing to compare against. so i loved every second of it. i think it's a masterwork. so deeply layered, look again... and again...

  • john Pippa 01/06/2010 8:04:00 AM

    Saw A Single Man three times and liked it better each time. Sorry to find you so critical. Try again? Maybe you saw too many movies that day?

  • David Ehrenstein 12/15/2009 12:40:00 AM

    http://www.laweekly.com/2009-12-10/film-tv/a-visible-man/

  • GiorgioNYC 12/09/2009 8:21:00 PM

    Since when is looking good in an overpriced shmatta a qualification for a film critic? I was dismayed when I heard Ford had decided to "direct" an adaptation of one of my favorite novels. Todd Haynes, as Foundas suggests, would've been far better. And making George suicidal betrays the novel. He's depressed over his lover Jim's death, but not to the point of wanting to kill himself. He takes pleasure in life (in teaching and in friendship, mostly) so why does Ford fall back on the melodramatic cliche of the suicidal homosexual? Ford should keep shilling his overpriced shmattas and stop trying to be something he's not -- an artist.

  • ronald p 12/09/2009 7:36:00 PM

    more film "criticism" from someone who would probably love to wear a tom ford suit but could not afford it and would never look good in it no matter what

 

Find A Film

for free stuff, film info & more!

Find A Coupon

Popular Coupons

  • Thumbnail

    Buy One Get One

    Spa Jolie formerly Randee Elaine Salon
    180 7th Ave. S.
    New York, NY 10014
  • Thumbnail

    $3 Off Any Order

    IRON SUSHI
    212 East 10th Street
    New York, NY 10032

Box Office

  1. Chronicle (2012/ I), 22.0 mil, 22.0 mil
  2. The Woman in Black, 20.9 mil, 20.9 mil
  3. The Grey, 9.3 mil, 34.6 mil
  4. Big Miracle, 7.8 mil, 7.8 mil
  5. Underworld: Awakening, 5.5 mil, 54.2 mil
  6. One for the Money, 5.2 mil, 19.6 mil
  7. Red Tails, 4.7 mil, 41.1 mil
  8. The Descendants, 4.6 mil, 65.5 mil
  9. Man on a Ledge, 4.4 mil, 14.6 mil
  10. Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, 3.8 mil, 26.7 mil
Movie Title, Weekly Earnings, Total Earnings

Trailers

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy