By Bryan Bierman
By Lindsey Rhoades
By Chaz Kangas
By Ben Westhoff and Sarah Purkrabek
By Jena Ardell
By Jesse Sendejas Jr.
By Katherine Turman
By Steve Weinstein
Though Ted Leo has been talking about the dismal economics of his stock-in-trade since at least as far back as a January 2009 Spin article in which he predicted he'd need a new job by 2010, he was as shocked as anyone else to wake up on an unpleasant, 100-degree day last week to the news that he was retiring. A website had reprinted a quote of his without context—"By next year, there's no way I'm going to be able to be on tour like I have been these last few years," he'd told Louisville's Velocity—underneath the headline "Ted Leo Mulling Retirement in 2011." Leo was not. On his blog, he called the whole thing a "classic journalistic hissy-fit" and added, with emphasis, "I'M SURE I'LL NEVER STOP MAKING MUSIC."
On the phone, the day before, from his house in Rhode Island, he didn't sound so sure. "There's just no way we can keep hammering along like we have been as everybody pushes on into their forties," says Leo, who is 39. In 2010, he and his band, the Pharmacists, were "essentially touring the same way that we were when we were in our early twenties"—i.e., when Leo was crashing mid-Atlantic basements with Chisel, the mod-punk quartet he founded as an undergraduate at Notre Dame. But the more pressing problem was one that the younger Leo couldn't have anticipated, back when he was sleeping on strangers' couches and playing to audiences that didn't always outnumber his band: Sales of his newest LP, The Brutalist Bricks, were lagging.
"It didn't matter when we had no expectations of selling more than a couple thousand records," Leo explains. "And I imagine—though I've never been there—it probably wouldn't matter as much if we were selling hundreds of thousands of records. But when you're selling in the tens of thousands of records, and half of your potential audience of, say, 40,000 sales are not buying it, then it actually, literally, does make a difference between being able to fund your tours and pay your rent while you're on tour, and not."
People even had the nerve to hit Leo up on Twitter to ask where they could find pirated copies of his new album: "I find it absolutely ridiculous that someone would approach the artist and say to them, 'Hey where can I . . . ?' " he says. "You know, it's available everywhere, it's 10 fucking dollars. You know how much people spend on beer and stupid shoes and American Apparel clothes every week? Ten dollars—it's 10 goddamn dollars. Dock yourself two beers this week, and you've got our album."
As a Bloomfield, New Jersey, teenager growing up just outside of New York in the '80s, Ted Leo was part of the first real generation of hardcore punk fans—young enough to worship Black Flag, but old enough to have seen them, too. By graduation, Leo was playing in bands of his own, as were most of the other people he knew. His progression as a musician mirrored the movement as a whole—by the time he'd reintroduced a generation of hardcore kids to the pleasures of the Jam, the future Pharmacists frontman had already tried his hand at everything from New York proto-thrash to D.C.'s signature emo-inflected post-hardcore. As his songwriting savvy grew, toward the middle of the decade, so did interest in Chisel. Like many punk acts at the end of the last century, the band suddenly found themselves in incongruous meetings with major labels, talking about potential deals. Leo passed on all of them and, in 1997, split the band up.
"By the end of the '90s," he remembers now, "I had been through the ringer with Chisel. We had been courted by major labels, and I came out of that deciding that I didn't want to be part of that world. That's when I started playing solo." He was turning 30. "I was like, 'You know what? I'm done. I'm just playing music at this point because I've got songs, and I can go play them, and that's what I'm going to do.' All of the good things that have come since then—honestly, when I really step back and think about it, I'm like, 'Bonus.' Because 10 years ago, I had already gotten to the point where I was like, 'Meh, I'm done.' "
Instead, Leo's post-Chisel career took off. In 2001, the Pharmacists signed to the sizeable indie Lookout!; their second release for the label, Hearts of Oak, came out in 2003. "That record came out and surprised everybody," he says now. "It surprised us. It surprised Lookout! in terms of how it sold and how well people responded to it. And all of a sudden, existing as a band that could be a self-sustaining prospect became a potentially viable option for us. It was always just out of reach, but so close that it always made sense to keep trying for it, you know?"
But Lookout! shuttered in 2005; Touch and Go, the similarly august imprint Leo signed to next, collapsed in 2009. Now, he puts out records on Matador, one of the few large-scale independent labels still standing, and faces the same dismal industry climate that has adversely impacted the sales of acts much bigger than his. He did it his way, but his way may have led him to something approaching a dead end. "I'm not going to lie," he says, "there are ways in which I've had to ask myself if my allegiance to the theology of all of this"—still touring in the same van, still selling T-shirts for $10, still dodging major labels—"throughout the years somehow hamstrung what myself and my songwriting might have been able to do otherwise."