Avenue Q fans are wearing their "It Sucks to Be Me" buttons with new flair now that the adult puppet show has won the Tony for Best Musical. At the production's post-Tony bash, company members were spinning the show's victory over Wicked as "the little musical that could." But the producers mounted a cutesy campaign to influence voters, with special promotional buttons ("Don't Suck, Vote Q") and a daffy "fundraising" pizza party at John's. Did the Harvey Weinsteinlite tactics charm voters into realizing that Wicked's a cheesy bore?
One thing's for sure: It clearly doesn't suck to originate Off-Broadway. Not only did the Vineyard's Avenue Q nab the evening's biggest prize, but Playwrights Horizon's I Am My Own Wife walked off (deservedly) with Best Play and Best Actor (for the multitudinous Jefferson Mays).
One downtown production didn't fare so well: The Public's Caroline, or Change left with only a single statuette (for featured performer Anika Noni Rose). How could the season's most ambitious musical go home nearly empty-handed? As one Broadway pundit explained to me, "Tony voters really couldn't get too enthusiastic for a work they respected but didn't necessarily enjoy."
More Tony Coverage
Go-Go Boy Wins Tony Award!
by Michael Musto
That's showbiz. The Times' public editor recently intimated that the Tonys are a crass marketing tool. (Say it isn't so!) But when acting honors go to Phylicia Rashad, Audra McDonald, and Brìan F. O'Byrne, even hardened cynics can momentarily believe.
Get the Theater Newsletter
Get a rundown of upcoming theater events and ticket deals in New York.