Best eatery in a supermarket (2008)

FAIRWAY CAFÉ

Ensconced comfortably above Fairway, a space that might be mistaken for a custodian's lair beneath an elementary school, FAIRWAY CAFÉ produces some of the best off-price fare on the Upper West, including lush sandwiches (try dilled egg salad or roast beef), burgers, and platters that mirror the abundance of vegetables and fruit downstairs.