Jell-O Pudding Pops (2008)

ShopRite or Stop & Shop

When Jell-O Pudding Pops went to the big freezer in the sky in the 90s, a cry went up from those of us who loved those weirdly chewy, icy treats. Even Bill Cosby, with his distinctively enthusiastic diction (Jello Puddin Pops is frozen pudding on a stick!) and his comforting dad-sweaters, couldnt help us. There was even an online petition agitating for their reincarnation. In 2004, pops-lovers got their wish when Popsicle brought them back, and now you can buy them at your local ShopRite or Stop & Shop.