Most vivacious veranda (2008)

Garden Bay

Sheepshead Bay is a mixed bag when it comes to eateries. Apart from the sainted Randazzo's and a Turkish spot or two, the food is uneven. One of your best all-around choices is Garden Bay, one of Gotham's few Armenian cafés (Armenians are more prone to open grocery stores). The twin lures are the kebabs grilling over lump charcoal right in the window—in order of desirability: baby lamb chops, the thick pork chop, and the skin-blackened trout—and a rear garden that makes you feel like you're somewhere in the Caucuses, instead of near the concrete bathtub of Sheepshead Bay.

More Awards from This Winner

Location Details

1788 Sheepshead Bay Road
Brooklyn NY 11235


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >