Best Ice Cream New York 2011 - Ample Hills Creamery
623 Vanderbilt Ave.
Brooklyn, NY 11238
Readers' Choice: Big Gay Ice Cream
There's a reason that Ample Hills Creamery sold out of all of its ice cream within its first four days of business, and a reason that it's still selling out of its salted crack caramel. It is indeed habit-forming, thanks to its great reserves of salty, burnt-caramel flavor and the sedimentary deposits of sugar-coated saltines and milk chocolate chunks buried in its depths. Impeccably creamy in texture, each scoop is like a bomb lobbed toward any measure of self-restraint. 623 Vanderbilt Avenue, Brooklyn, 347-240-3926, amplehills.com