After Fall, Winter
Once nominated for Gawker's "Douche of the Decade," filmmaker-actor Eric Schaeffer (If Lucy Fell) casts himself yet again as an ideal—a fragile romantic who fucks a model-thin beauty while musing on sexual kink, suicide, and relationships—in another sanctimonious dose of talk-therapy cinema. It's not necessary to see 1997's Fall to follow this sequel, in which Schaeffer's now middle-age Manhattan novelist Michael scurries off to Paris to escape his loneliness, faded career, and six-figure debt. More than a week of screen time and a punishing 130-minute run time, his uncouth American bluntness repels before inexplicably charming half-his-age Sophie (Lizzie Brocheré), a caretaker of terminally ill patients who moonlights as a dominatrix—a fetish she keeps from Michael, just as he hides his preference for strap-on humiliations. Like talking to a mirror, the two act as Schaeffer's neurotic halves: She identifies as more masculine in her fear of intimacy; he cries before yoga class when faced with some harsh reality. A feebly earnest subplot involving a 13-year-old girl dying of leukemia and a gypsy street scammer don't distract from what frustrates even more than the risible ending of Shakespearean martyrdom: Schaeffer can't be trusted or believed as a broken man—he's got no humility.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.