As Tears Go By
"So now, my children, I'll tell you the legend of the camel," a Mongolian grandfather intones as The Story of the Weeping Camel opens. This magical film, a "narrative documentary" (or so its makers call it) with the aura of a fairy tale, unfolds amid the scrubby brushland of the Gobi Desert, where nomads live in yurts, ride camels, and tend to herds of sheep and goats as they have for centuries. The granddaughter of nomads, Byambasuren Davaa (who co-wrote and -directed the film with Luigi Falorni) was inspired by a movie she remembered from her Mongolian childhood about a mother camel who rejects her newborn calf, before the two are reconciled by means of an ancient musical ceremony.
Influenced by classic documentaries such as Robert Flaherty's Nanook of the North, Davaa and Falorni cast a nomadic family of four generations living in three yurts, who play themselves in sometimes carefully planned scenarios. Shooting this family in the southern Gobi during the brief camel-birthing season, the filmmakers stumbled across the story they were seeking. As Camel begins, the lovely Odgoo (Odgerel Ayusch) and her husband, Ikchee (Ikhbayar Amgaabazar), along with their parents, grandparents, and two young sons, are assisting the animals in their labors. All goes well until the difficult birth of a beautiful white calf (called Botok) stretches over two days, straining the mother camel (played by a dromedary named Ingen Temme) to her limits.
Beyond its rare visions of remote vistas, Camel's great charm lies in its seeming simplicity. The camera records the events of the dayfrom a little girl's tears to an afternoon sandstormwith a childlike clarity and curiosity. When Odgoo's sons set out on camelback to the nearest settlement (some 50 kilometers away), to find the violinist needed to heal the rift between mother and baby, the camera notes the outside world's encroachments on a traditional lifestylesatellite dishes, video games, the ubiquitous motorcycles that serve as alternatives to animal transportation. But these are offered without heavy-handed judgments; the filmmakers merely note the coexistence of modernity and ritual.
Sometimes the nearly too perfect images border on kitsch. But with its stately pacing (and consistent with its broader theme about the need for belonging), Camel conveys a sense of an indigenous culture whose relationship to the earth and to nature is shaped not by conquest but by collaboration. Perhaps that's why the film's camel stars are also credited as performers. Living alongside these otherworldly creatures, whose stubborn independence shines through their wild, bovine eyes, must inspire a profound respect. Infinitely serviceable tanks of the desert, built to withstand the harshest climatic conditions, they may be coaxed, but never forced. And when they weep, their tears seem real.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.