Defamation Eyes the Modern Face of Anti-Semitism
Jewish Israeli director Yoav Shamir's cheerfully incendiary documentary about the modern face of anti-Semitism begins with Shamir (Checkpoint) blundering, Michael Moore–style, through the New York offices of the Anti-Defamation League, where Abe Foxman and his minions dutifully rout out a "spike" in anti-Semitic incidents that include office workers denied vacation for the High Holy Days and a policeman's racial slur overheard at a funeral. From there, it's off to Israel, where teens about to depart on a tour of the Polish concentration camps are briefed for their journey: "You will see that they do not like us." At first, it seems as if Shamir, too, may be indoctrinating us. But as he continues his world tour, his case—and the film—becomes more carefully nuanced, with evidence of overt hate crimes (a stabbing spree in a Moscow synagogue) juxtaposed against Foxman's Chicken Little hysteria, on the one hand, and Holocaust Industry author Norman Finkelstein's virulent anti-Zionism on the other. Does anti-Semitism exist or is it a construct of America's powerful, pro-Israel lobby? Are Jewish fears of a second Holocaust justified or merely a product of the same fearmongering that gives rise to all forms of extremism? Is Venezuela really the second-most anti-Semitic country in the world, after Iran? Like most good documentaries, Defamation poses more questions than it purports to answer, before arriving at the mildly reductive postulation that what's past is past.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.