How Ralph Fiennes Brought His Marvelous Invisible Woman To The Screen
Portrait by Chad Griffith for The Village Voice
If you're a person alive in this age, Ralph Fiennes has at some point probably made you hate him. As the Nazi Amon Goeth in 1993's Schindler's List, Fiennes embodied one of history's great evils, somehow making being utterly detestable compelling. In Martin McDonagh's riotous, under-regarded In Bruges, Fiennes spat the vilest, most hilarious profanities as a hit man's boss out to right his subordinate's cock-ups. And in film after film of that Boy Wizard Meets Esteemed British Thespians series, he starred as an avatar of wickedness so wicked he couldn't be named — so we'll not get into that here.
Now, though, cinema's consummate villain wants you to know that the bloke he's playing only seems like a heavy.
"I like it when people say they don't know what to make of him, because that means he doesn't seem like a complete shit," Fiennes says.
That not-a-shit, of course, is Charles Dickens himself, the man who pretty much invented the modern ideas of Christmas and childhood. The Invisible Woman, which Fiennes also directed and helped develop, is based on the book of the same title by Claire Tomalin, whose research laid bare a Victorian scandal that admirers of the great man have often preferred to overlook: the time Dickens left his tireless wife and heap of children in order to set up house with Nelly Ternan (played by Felicity Jones), a much younger woman whose reputation, afterward, never quite recovered.
"It's a really interesting time to get one's head around, before the great flexibility that we have today, where people get divorced three times before they're 40," says the actor and director, who splits his time between New York and London. "Whatever taboos a society shares, people are still falling in love and lusting for each other."
The film is alive with love and lust. But also longing and disquiet, that curious feeling of being the normal person in the life of someone extraordinary. It's excellent, touched with that lived-in, slightly shabby feel of life as it's lived that too many period pieces lack. The interiors are cramped and chilly; lights are dim and flickering; hair often looks a touch greasy. This is far from the chipperness of contemporary Dickensiana — that plummy holiday pudding thick with virginal naïfs, caroling orphans, and triumphant human decency.
Still, there's a radiance to The Invisible Woman. It's in Fiennes's characterization of the author himself, a man who — perhaps suspecting the challenge he would pose to later performers — dubbed himself "The Inimitable." Here, the man of letters is a tireless celebrity, the life not just of the party but the age itself. In public, Fiennes's Dickens seems made up entirely of charisma and whiskers and the awe of those around him. With his pal Wilkie Collins (Tom Hollander), a fervent opponent of traditional marriage, Dickens stages amateur plays and afterward hosts lavish soirees that seep into the dawn. Later in the film, we see Dickens giving some of his famous public readings, as hammy and self-regarding in his performance as Fiennes is scrupulous.
Dickens may dominate this world, but this story is Nelly's. "It was the life of Nelly that always moved me," says Fiennes. "Dickens was a fantastic firework that was going to be a part of it. If it became Dickens's film, then we were making the wrong film."
Instead, this is the story of how Nelly Ternan became a mistress. "At first it's about the journey, the incremental stages, Dickens circling her," Fiennes explains. "I wanted to avoid obvious moments, the locking eyes across a crowded room. In life, relationships happen incrementally, and attractions between people build, and people aren't always quite clear of their motivations toward each other."
Fiennes's direction is steady and sturdy, stripped of the flash of Coriolanus, his previous feature. Like many actors turned directors, he elicits strong performances, and two here are heartbreakers: First is Nelly, of course, as a woman in love with a man the world loves, too — a love she can't ever publicly declare. "What fascinated me is how she negotiates the social complexity of being pursued by Dickens. What choices does she have? She can't marry him."
One surprise, for Fiennes and likely for viewers unfamiliar with Tomalin's two books about Dickens and Ternan: Victorian society did allow for some unorthodox personal lives. "These are flesh-and-blood human beings with bodily functions," Fiennes says. "Nelly's mother [played by Kristin Scott Thomas with transactional frankness] is a really interesting figure. She acquiesced to the affair. The family was hard up, and she knew that the reality was that Nelly could be his mistress, and live well, as long as all the social taboos were respected. That's in Claire's book. She writes about actresses in the theater who would have lovers and their own arrangements. As long as things were under the radar, people got on with it."
The other heartbreaker is Catherine Dickens (Joanna Scanlan), the wife the great man left. In one of the film's most upsetting scenes, Dickens proves less circumspect than his mistress, going so far as to pen a letter to the press to announce the end of his marriage — referred to as "some domestic trouble of mine of long standing" — all without consulting Catherine.
"You wish he'd just have shut up," Fiennes says, a little pained. "Look, you've fallen in love, you want to leave the marriage and get on with it, but don't go around telling the world you're the aggrieved party. I see a man in his middle years, flailing, one who's a bit like a child who thrashes out defensively in the face of criticism. He dishonored her a bit."
The film does the opposite. Scanlan's Catherine is the slightly frowsy mother of many who just doesn't have it in her to keep up with her husband's relentless high-spiritedness. Yet there she sits, at parties and plays, just out of the spotlight, supportive yet beat.
Either of these women could, in some ways, be the invisible woman of the title. Both performances are superb, as is Fiennes, who credits a little of what he knows about working with actors to his time with Steven Spielberg, possibly the closest an artist of this era has come to Dickens's belovedness. "It was as if he kept probing me, trying to find that moment when an actor's preparedness was slightly broken," Fiennes recounts. "He would say things like, 'Change that word; you've said it like that. Do something just a little bit different.' He was pushing for the little surprising bursts of energy — a turn of the head or an unexpected emphasis."
As an actor, Fiennes has now completed a double hat-trick of quintessential Britondom — Hamlet (for which he won a Tony), Wuthering Heights' Heathcliff, J.K. Rowling's big bad wizard, The Avengers' John Steed, and James Bond's boss, M — likely the only role he ever took over from Dame Judi Dench. ("I'm not sure how happy she is about it," he laughs, before confirming that the next Bond movie most likely shoots in late 2014.) Next up, he's hoping to return to the theater, and then more directing and performing.
And reading. Before The Invisible Woman, he wasn't much of a Dickens fan, but the experience of making the film, and of appearing as the convict Magwitch in Mike Newell's recent Great Expectations, stirred in him love and insight for both the man and his work. "The cold-hearted Estella of Great Expectations, I think, was a version of Nelly," Fiennes says. "She was quite difficult to get, and I think in his imaginative world, the morally flawed Pip is Dickens. We used Pip's famous love speech to Estella in the film. It's one of the most beautiful declarations of love ever written, a man saying, 'This is all of me, the bad and the good in me.' That seems to come from his heart. He knew, in the end, he had damaged his family, but he lays his heart on the line for her, and I can't help loving him for that."
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.