With hardly any dialogue, and seductive black-and-white cinematography, writer-director Rob Tregenza shows rather than tells a sort of love rhombus between a small-town priest (Tom Gilroy) and three patients at a nearby mental institution. Tregenza has a great talent for choreography and pacing. A scene that consists of a continuous pan , as nurses and patients fight over the arrangement of a group of chairs whilea psychotic rock band plays along with a harp, is a brilliant piece of Altman-esque staging. But lurking under the skin of this art film is a fairly conventional melodrama. If the silent confrontation between the priest, the organist he's fallen for, and her mother had any dialogue, it would be equally at home on Guiding Light. A scene of reconciliation in which the organist teaches her unstable rival a childlike lick at the piano could have dropped out of a Robert Zemeckis flick. Tregenza sometimes shoves the love story into a straitjacket, but his facility with visual narrative is fascinating and even liberating.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.