Jeanne and the Perfect Guy
Here's something you don't see very often: an ACT UP march in Paris in which the principals burst into song. But the scene's strange mix of emotionsjoyous musical outbursts in the midst of a politically charged occasionis typical of Jeanne and the Perfect Guy, a contemporary musical in the tradition of Jacques Demy's Umbrellas of Cherbourg. The new movie's heroine (a radiant Virginie Ledoyen) is a travel agency receptionist who leaps from one sexual entanglement to the next, hoping to find her ideal man. Trouble is, she has only a vague notion of what she's searching for, so virtually any man her agefrom the denim-clad motorcycle messenger who brings her packages to the vain executives at her travel agency office to a handsome stranger on the Métrois worth a try.
Though she's something of a wildcat in bed, Jeanne has a short attention span when it comes to relationships. The exception is Olivier, played by Mathieu Demy, the son of directors Jacques Demy and Agnès Varda. But Olivier has a secret: he's HIV positive. As usual, Jeanne's morning-after reaction is breezy denial: "That's okay," she chirps. "We used a condom." At this point, the film seems to divide in half: the less interesting story follows Jeanne's almost delusional faith in love as a great healer. The other thread involves François (Jacques Bonnaffee), a gay professor-activist who knows both Jeanne and Olivier, and has far more depth. As a musical, Jeanne and the Perfect Guy suffers from a treacly sameness in its songs (the only notable exception is a number performed by the African cleaning staff at Jeanne's office). As a love story, the movie is alternately charming and grim. In the end, the message is, the more people professand sing aboutlove, the less they feel it.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.