Memory Lane: 1960s Boyhood in Sweet Coming-of-Ager That's What I Am
Those of us old enough to remember The Wonder Years (cough) will recognize the structure and style of Thats What I Am, a winsome reminiscence of early-1960s suburban boyhood, in which lessons of tolerance share time with the first stirrings in a young mans pants. Just entering high school, Andy Nichol (Chase Ellison) has a favorite teacher (Ed Harris), a favorite girl (Mia Rose Frampton), and a big red target (Alexander Walters) onto which he and the entire student body can project their anxieties. Big G, as the latter is called, is a ginger Frankenstein with huge prosthetic ears; even Andy, a sensitive aspiring writer, has assimilated the poor treatment G receives as normal. Director and writer Michael Pavone establishes an unhurried pace, setting up a series of thematic T-balls (dont be a bully; live and let live) and then mildly knocking them into the infield. Greg Kinnear provides the narration as modern-day Andy, his dulcet, small-town radio voice a good fit for a story of bittersweet nostalgia. The writing hits the weeds on occasion, but Pavone evokes with feeling adolescence as a series of outlandish physical punishments and sweetly remembered firsts.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.