Rich Man, Poor Man
About Will Smith's estimable talents, there is no doubt. Six Degrees of Separation, Ali, um . . . the "Parents Just Don't Understand" videothe man's got skills to pay the bills, yours, mine, and his. That he seldom uses them, or their attendant clout, is dispiriting. This is an actor coming off a streak that includes, in order and with no omissions, Men in Black II; Bad Boys II; I, Robot; Shark Tale; and Hitch. With that barely breathing body of work, he's single-handedly programming Cinemax and Showtime but creating a legacy better served by Fresh Prince reruns.
What better path to redemption, then, than a film about, gosh, redemption? The Pursuit of Happyness is the true-life tale of Chris Gardner, who, it can be said without fear of treading into cliché, lived a rags-to-riches life. In the early 1980s, Gardner pounded the San Francisco pavement trying to off-load the expensive, perhaps even unnecessary, medical scanners into which he had sunk his family's nest egg. As the bank account emptied, so did his home: His girlfriend left him with their son, and by 1983, Gardner was sleeping in San Francisco's Union Square and eating in soup kitchens.
Yet at the same time, Gardner was also interning, gratis, at Dean Witter. Eventually he wound up not only securing a job with the stock brokerage, but forming his own investment company, which he's currently in the midst of selling for multimillions.A fresh prince, indeed.
Smith loves this guyor, at the very least, this role, a feel-bad part in a feel-good movie about a man whose life crumbles and collapses bit by agonizing bit till it's made whole and happy in the final minutes. Playing against his standard type (wiseass talking smack in the back row), Smith shows necessary restraint, but in the end you're constantly aware that he's reminding us of his range: I can grin and frown, see?
The movie, the first English-language film directed by Italian Gabriele Muccino, is too emotionally slick to work, too visually glib to have an impact, made by people who think grit is something that's brought in by the prop department: We get Will Smith with a 1980s 'fro, a hangdog mustache, and shabby suitsa movie star playing dress-down dress-up. The only actor the audience will buy is young Jaden Christopher Syre Smith in the part of Chris's sonbecause he is, in fact, Will Smith's son, and their scenes together possess an instantly recognizable intimacy that can't be feigned or forced. There is no denying the tear-jerking power of the scene in a bus station bathroom where the son passes out on his father's lap as the old man guards the door from interlopers who would disturb their last sanctuary.
Still, The Pursuit of Happyness only digs deep enough to impart something you already know: It's far better to be rich than broke. Draped in the flag, which flutters in almost every scene to remind us that Gardner's is the quintessential tale of the American dream come true, the movie eschews the darkest parts of its subject's backstory: his abusive stepfather, the mother who did time in prison for trying to burn down the house with the stepfather in it, the years a young Gardner spent bouncing around foster homes. We know nothing of this man, save for the fact that he made a terrible investment that cost him his woman and his apartmentand that two hours later, he's rich because the end scroll tells us so. Go see this and you're just making the wealthy a little wealthier.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.