Taking a Second Look at John Carpenter's 1988 They Live
Remember how the design and F/X work in Elysium was so much more persuasive than its populist morals?
Medium and message are more congruent in John Carpenter's wonderful 1988 sci-fi agitprop They Live, which cost a thrifty $3 million and, frankly, looks it. The picture stars one Roderick George Toombs — better known to pro-wrestling devotees as "Rowdy" Roddy Piper — as a strapping, backstory-free drifter who boxcars into Los Angeles seeking work.
As with Keanu Reeves in the similar The Matrix, Piper's limited range is a feature, not a bug. (Could Daniel Day-Lewis improve upon Piper's line reading when tasked to tell a well-dressed older woman, "You know, you look like your head fell in the cheese dip back in 1957"?)
A homeless camp that welcomes him in turns out to be a base for the resistance against — oh, hey, didn't you know? — Earth's capitalist alien occupiers, revealed when you wear the right sunglasses as bulbous-eyed ghouls, like live-action Matt Groening drawings.
These Wayfarers block "the signal" that hides the aliens' appearance and reveal the sans-serif orders encoded on every billboard and magazine cover: "OBEY"; "MARRY AND REPRODUCE."
There's something winning about the fairy-tale simplicity of Carpenter's allegory — compared to this, RoboCop is Candide. Its action scenes are unmemorable, with the exception of a gonzo brawl between Piper and Keith David; They Live is, to scramble its most famous line, better at chewing bubblegum than kicking ass.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.