The Elfin Man Takes Manhattan, Faces the Wrath of Caan
In this wan Christmas concoction, lumbering human Buddy (Will Ferrell) leaves the elfin toy-making community that raised him and heads south to find his Hobbesian father Walter Hobbs (James Caan), a mercenary children's-book publisher who (as Santa notes) is firmly on the naughty list. In the tradition of Midnight Cowboy and Splash, Buddy's naïveté gets a Manhattan workout: He rhapsodizes over a greasy spoon advertising the "world's best coffee," delights in revolving doors, and mimics his former employment by working as an elf in a department store, where he gets canned for pointing out that the bogus Saint Nick sits on a "throne of lies." Elf works best as a rapid-fire series of sight gags and absurd remarks: Buddy notes that the four elf food groups are candy, candy canes, candy corn, and syrup; an experienced toy-maker, he can whip off the Mona Lisa on his Etch A Sketch. The high point belongs to dwarf of the moment Peter Dinklage, as a Midasizing kiddy-lit genius, a Pynchonesque prima donna with a short (as they say) fuse.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.