The Marginally Compelling Sincerely Yours
Closing the fall edition of MOMA's once-a-month ContemporAsian series—an ongoing survey of little-seen festival fare—is a marginalized film about marginalized people that is, at best, marginally compelling. In Taipei, Javanese migrant worker Setia (Lola Amaria) serves illegally as a maid at a massage parlor, making far less than a living wage. Hers is a thankless existence that undocumented Thai laborer Supayong (Tropical Malady's Banlop Lomnoi) can relate to—his forced hustle includes construction-site thievery and gay sexual favors on trains. Out of basic human necessity and perhaps a kicked-in survival instinct, the two find and cling to each other for support and hotel-room romping, clumsily communicating through their mutual second language of Mandarin Chinese. Film scholar Rich Lee's directorial debut—originally titled Detours to Paradise and inspired by Fassbinder's Ali: Fear Eats the Soul—clearly wants to expose the vicious cycle endured by the underclass as they suffer daily indignities while fretting about deportation as a fate much worse. Yet even with the elegant craftsmanship of Hou Hsiao-hsien's regular cinematographer and editor, and dialogue as sparse as fellow countryman Tsai Ming-liang's, Lee's film deals in fusty anti-globalization sentiments and mostly meanders—aimlessly, impassively, and away from the rich Taiwanese canon.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.