village voice
RSS/Podcast feed for Village Voice News Status Ain't Hood
Eerie Misanthropic Wednesday
City Gourmet
Win an Office Party from City Gourmet Eatery!
Latino Poets Society
Enter for your chance to win tickets to The Latino Poet’s Society Spoken Word Tour at The Cherry Lane Theater in Greenwich Village!
Jammin' with Jazz at Lincoln Center
Win admission for two to one performance at Dizzy's Club Coca-Cola, New York’s hottest jazz club, plus a collection of jazz CDs and more!
Bash'd
Enter to win tickets to a performance of Bash'd: A Gay Rap Opera!
Film
Man With No Name Tells a Story of Heroics, Color Coordination
by J. Hoberman
August 17th, 2004 12:00 AM

Sword-crossed lovers: Leung, Cheung
photo: Miramax Films
Hero
Directed by Zhang Yimou
Miramax, opens August 27
Hero, Zhang Yimou's impeccably crafted, all-star martial arts extravaganza, is the essence of shallow gravitas. Told, largely in flashback, by a nameless warrior to the third century B.C. king of Qin (eventually China's first emperor), the movie is proudly two-dimensional. The heroic Jet Li has no name and less personality, particularly as he's surrounded by the likes of Tony Leung, Maggie Cheung, and Zhang Ziyi.

The filmmaker's follow-up, House of Flying Daggers, due to open later this year, may have more humor and greater narrative intricacy, but Hero is a virtuoso performance. The action is wittily aestheticized, with swordplay variously compared to music, calligraphy, and theater. The heavens rain arrows, and in one choreographed number Maggie Cheung takes them for partners in a whirling-dervish dance. The most spectacular duel is an aerial ballet in which the combatants skip like stones over a sylvan lake. Many scenes are color-coded: The autumn leaves turn red as one character dies. Hero was shot by Chris Doyle, and although it's not nearly as expressionist as his work for Wong Kar-wai, its look is loud.

Hero's backstory is also action-packed. Having acquired the most costly movie ever made in China back in 2002, Miramax sat on its U.S. release, diddling with the running time, until other forces came into play. Quentin Tarantino persuaded his padrone Harvey Weinstein to restore the movie to its original length. Then, Weinstein's estranged padrone Michael Eisner released some extra bucks to facilitate the movie's release, acting to placate the Chinese officials whose help he needs for his Sino Disney World.

Such power politics are not inappropriate given the film's cartoon ideology. There's more than a bit of Leni Riefenstahl to Hero—and not just because of the implied "worship" in the title or Zhang's homage to Star Wars' famous Triumph of the Will swipe. Hero's vast imperial sets and symmetrical tumult, its decorative dialectical montage and sanctimonious traditionalism, its glorification of ruthless leadership and self-sacrifice on the altar of national greatness, not to mention the sense that this might somehow stoke the engine of political regeneration, are all redolent of fascinatin' fascism.

More by J. Hoberman
Michael Haneke's Funny Games: One-Trick Phony
Blind Mountain's Chinese torture trumps Haneke's tortured antics

Radicals Get Retrospectives
Renegade Georges Franju, meet rebel Kim Ki-young

Manoel de Oliveira: Man of the Century
BAM celebrates 100 years of a Portuguese master

CJ7: ET Phone Hong Kong
Tamer f/x and a cute little gremlin in Stephen Chow's new one

Paranoid Park Returns Gus Van Sant to his Roots
Namely disaffected youth, shoestring budgets

Add a Comment

Not ? Login as a different user.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By submitting a comment, you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms of Use.

Login or Register

Login or register to have a chance to win Free Stuff, subscribe to newsletters and much more!

Login Register


The Village Voice Ad Index
The Village Voice Guide To Atlantic City

» click here to see more...

The Village Voice Summer Guide 2008

» click here to see more...

The Village Voice Summer 2008 Education Supplement

» click here to see more...

The Village Voice Spring Arts Supplement

» click here to see more...