235 Mulberry St.
New York, NY 10012
Critics' Pick
Best Of

Liz+Barclay The+ideal+housewife%26%23146%3Bs+fine+pizza.


  • Sun-Thu 11:30am-11pm, Fri-Sat 11:30am-12am
  • $$
  • Brunch, Dinner, Lunch
  • Full bar
  • Street Parking
  • Reservations Accepted
AJ Pappalardo grew up in a pizzeria: His father, Giuseppe Pappalardo, was the Joe in Joe & Pat’s, the beloved Staten Island pie shop that opened in 1960 after Joe and Pat emigrated from Naples. In 2010, the younger Pappalardo opened his own place with help from the elder, and he tapped another Italian-American Staten Islander, Al DiMeglio, to helm the kitchen, though there’s plenty of family oversight: Many dishes at Rubirosa come from AJ’s mother Lena’s personal recipes. While seasonal specials rotate frequently, much of the menu remains steadfast. We’re smitten with the classic pizza, a crisp, thin-crust iteration with tangy red sauce and dollops of dry mozzarella that’s a throwback to Joe & Pat’s standard pie. The pastas, all made in-house, are not to be missed; we like the cavatelli with broccoli rabe and sausage, ditto the spaghetti chitarra with red sauce and Parmesan. A wine list assembled by general manager Bari Musacchio features mostly Italian bottles, several from Arianna Occhipinti, wines Musacchio praises as a perfect fit for the restaurant’s concept and philosophy: welcoming and nuanced, approachable yet challenging, but, most important, fun and delicious.

Related Stories (7)

  • At Rubirosa, the Fast Pace Is Blessing and Curse
    2 years ago by Hannah Palmer Egan

    As we wrote our list of 99 Essential Restaurants™ in Lower Manhattan, we spoke to many of the chefs, owners, and general managers who run the restaurants. We asked them to tell us about the history of their neighborhoods and e...

  • Five Dishes We've Been Digging Around Town
    2 years ago by Laura Shunk

    We often dine out in the city multiple times per day, and so we've begun amassing notes on the dishes we taste that strike just the right note. Our five highlights this week include a simple salad, a platter of bacon, and ice cream ...

  • 10 Great NYC Dishes For Two
    2 years ago by Nicole Schnitzler

    When your dinner party sees a bigger dish variety and a smaller tab, it's hard to argue against shared plates (sorry, solo dish devotees). And while you'll have to be on board with your dining partner's food tastes, these medium-for...

  • A Tale of the Feast of Seven Fishes -- and 10 Places to Eat It in NYC
    2 years ago by Hannah Palmer Egan

    Every year, Italians the world over celebrate La Vigilia de Natale, or the Labor of Mary, with a bereaved act of abstention: in honor of the birth of Christ, neo-Romans fast the day away, and, in one final tithe, opt away from red m...

Load More Articles


View All

More Italian Restaurants in Nolita

View All

More Italian Restaurants in New York


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >