Search More


Jacob's Pickles

509 Amsterdam Ave. New York, NY 10024 | West 80s | 212-470-5566

Location Description:

Despite the "all pickle" promise of the restaurant’s name, the menu's bedrock at Jacob's Pickles is a series of biscuit-borne sandwiches. The breakfast ones feature eggs, gravy, cheddar, ham, and mushroom gravy; while the more-substantial full meal variety stuff the fluffy, outsize biscuits with friend chicken, bacon, pickle slaw, and fried green tomatoes--creating a gutbomb of mind-boggling proportions, and making these "sandwiches" impossible to eat without a knife and fork. Oh, and as if that weren't enough, they come sided with cheese grits. There are omelets, pancakes, mussels, and seared salmon, as well, but these seem a little forced compared to the southern-food theme. Of course, you can sup entirely on pickles, which are available in myriad varieties in individual servings or ganged up in platters, but one suspects these are intended solely as drinking snacks at this spacious Upper West Side restaurant with a booze menu that overshadows the food. --Robert Sietsema

Related Stories (4)


  • Cuisine(s): New American, Soul Food, Southern
  • Hours: Daily 10am-12am
  • Price: $$, $$$
  • Serving: Brunch, Dinner, Late Night, Lunch
  • Alcohol: Full bar
  • Reservations: Not Accepted
  • Parking: Street
  • Payment Types: All Major Credit Cards
  • Features: Takeout

Related Stories

  • Fork in the Road: Lists
    Step aside cupcakes, hand pies, and -- yes, you too -- cronuts/doughsants, right now, NYC has all eyes on the biscuit. These soft and flaky staples of Southern cuisine have been working...
  • Fork in the Road: Lists
    Among iconic American foodstuffs, fried chicken has the ability to generate a particular patriotic zeal, and southerners are by far the most vocal (rightfully so). The dish has a dark past:...
  • Fork in the Road: Cocktails
    On Wednesday night, Jacob's Pickles hosted a sour beer tasting with drafts from a number of domestic breweries; Bruery Hottenroth's Berliner Weisse, the Allagash Golden Brett, Jolly...
  • Fork in the Road: Featured
    Topped with bacon, slaw, and fried green tomatoes and sided with cheese grits, the fried chicken biscuit sandwich at Jacob's PicklesUpdate: We have revised our guide. Be sure to read our new...