Search More



94 University Place New York, NY 10003 | East Village | 212-776-1830

Location Description:

Don’t be alarmed that this place is a partial offshoot of Caliente Cab Co., one of the city’s most notorious (and notoriously bad) margarita mills: The food at Union Square’s Tortaria is about a zillion times better. Not that it attempts too much—the bedrock of the menu is a series of the Mexican sandwiches called tortas, here rendered on small brioche rolls rather than the oblong telera bread. Fillings, not all of them doctrinaire, run to chicken milanese, pulled pork, and crispy eggplant, the latter one of several vegetarian options on the menu. Then there are tacos, soups, salads, and sides. But the real treasure of Tortaria, which is rather charmingly decorated and has a nice layout featuring plenty of window seating, are the off-price drinks, especially a straight-up margarita that regales you with plenty of alcohol. With drinks this good and cheap, the food feels almost like an afterthought. Like its sire, Caliente Cab Company, Tortaria might be considered a margarita mill, too—only the gastropub version of it.

Related Stories (4)


  • Cuisine(s): Mexican
  • Hours: Sun-Thu 11am-12am, Fri-Sat 11am-1am
  • Price: $$
  • Serving: Dinner, Lunch, Snack Food
  • Alcohol: Full bar
  • Reservations: Not Accepted
  • Parking: Street
  • Payment Types: All Major Credit Cards

Related Stories

  • Fork in the Road: Lists
    [See More Favorites: 5 Cooling Dishes to Help You Beat the Heat | 5 Best Cheap Eats on Eldridge Street] Despite the hype, Baja-style fish tacos have never quite gotten the traction here...
  • Fork in the Road: Food News
    Cinco De Mayo is just around the corner and that calls for some rounds of tequila and maybe a margarita or two. Here's a round-up of five places where you can get discounted booze on the...
  • Fork in the Road: Bartending
    Located near Union Square, Tortaria is a Mexican eatery and bar that serves up one of the best margaritas in the city. Responsible for this amazing concoction is head bartender Diego...
  • Fork in the Road: Featured
    The house margarita at Empellón Cocina By legend, the margarita was invented around 1940 in an Italian restaurant in Ensenada, Mexico, to commemorate the visit of the daughter of...