Search More


Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano

1524 Neptune Ave. Brooklyn, NY 11224 | Coney Island | 718-372-8606

Location Description:

Located in the weed-choked neighborhood where Woody Guthrie lived out his final years, Totonno's sports the best fresh mozzarella of any pizzeria in town. That this cheese is a little soupy, making the pie damp, is fine with us. Just grab a fork!

Related Stories (8)


  • Cuisine(s): Pizza
  • Hours: Sun, Wed-Sat 12pm-8pm
  • Price: $
  • Serving: Dinner, Lunch
  • Reservations: Not Necessary
  • Parking: Street
  • Payment Types: cash
  • Attire: Casual
  • Other Locations:

Related Stories

  • Fork in the Road: Lists
    When the weather's nice, nothing beats a trip to our city's shores. Whether taking in the waning historic charm of a bygone era at Coney Island or parking yourself on a dune in The...
  • Fork in the Road: Lists
    We've been fuming since TripAdvisor's bogus pizza rankings placed New York fourth in the country this summer. The list--a product of crowdsourcing gone awry--proved to be ultimately useless,...
  • Fork in the Road: Critic's Picks
    From Totonno's limited roster of toppings, we ordered Italian sausage and garlic. Coney Island's ancient pizza parlor Totonno's reopened recently after a five-month hiatus following...
  • Fork in the Road: Food News
    Beloved Coney Island pizza parlor and New York institution, Totonno's, which had been closed since Hurricane Sandy hit the neighborhood, is back in business, reports Grub Street. As soon as...
  • Fork in the Road: Lists
    You're never without a fresh hot flatbread at Yemen Cafe. By my estimate, there are at least 15,000 restaurants in Brooklyn, and I love about 200 of them at any given time. So this list...
  • Fork in the Road: By Fork in the Road Staff
    Dear Santa, We've been pretty good this year. We supported the New York establishments that we love and worked tirelessly to perfect our homemade baked goods. We buried our heads in...
  • Fork in the Road: Food News
    Some restaurants in Sandy-stricken areas like Lower Manhattan and Red Hook have been able to get back on their feet in the wake of Hurricane Sandy. But in Coney Island, the beloved...
  • Dining:
    TOTONNO PIZZERIA NAPOLITANO 1524 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn, 718-372-8606. This Coney Islander is the best pizza parlor in town, perhaps in the world, a place whose uncompromising crust is...

Best of Award Recipient