Folk-Rock Up-and-Comer Goes by Book, Places Pretty Products
If you had a voice like Brandi Carlile's, you'd take great pleasure in using it. I expect you'd spend hours in the shower learning to negotiate said voice's equally slippery high and low registers; you'd hone its steely edge until you could drive it straight through listeners' foreheads; you'd probably hold long notes like dark, trembling fruit until they ripened, swelled, and burst their innards all over you. How do I know this? Pure scientific deduction, my friendThom Yorke owns a similar voice, and he does all the same shit.
Unfortunately, too many of Brandi's songs sound like by-the-book Bends outtakes. Since that book includes a "Prettiness" chapter, the results aren't always unlistenable, but she only attains greatness on three numbers that folk-rock like the '65 Beatles. "Closer to You" was one of the highlights of the Traveling Pants soundtrack, and makes me wander around the shower singing "I've Just Seen a Face." "What Can I Say" had the misfortune of running under a trite Grey's Anatomy sum-up-alogue. "Happy" hasn't yet popped up anywhere else (keep an eye on ER!), but its wistful acoustic chugalug recalls the more subtle shades of Norah Jones. If that's not a ringing endorsement, remember the contextamid subpar Radiohead, Norah sounds pretty good.
Brandi Carlile plays Mercury Lounge February 13.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.