Let me defrock you, oh liar of the orifice, but about yer blues . . .
There's a critical fervor surrounding Abattoir Blues/The Lyre of Orpheus, the new double album reuniting Nick Cave with his Bad Seeds, over the idea that the godfather of the underworld has (finally) discovered a sensitive side. Citing the absence of deathly endings, and the offering of a few crass jokesone, in particular, involving Orpheus and his orificereviewers conclude that Nick is lightening up in his old age: not so obsessed with fatality and ugly stuff.
Is Nick, a few years late, becoming a sensitive '90s man? (I'm Australian, I can call him Nick, as long as I pronounce it "Nhiiyhck" and put my hand on my heart as I say it.) It's true that even Abattoir Bluesthe album's more hardheaded halfis full of roguish moments, as when Nick asks his object of desire, "Do you feel what I feel, dear?" after waking up "with a frappuccino in my hand." He goes on to declare that "mass extinction, darling, hypocrisy; these things are not good for me," twisting his reputedly vicious character into a doddering, soft oldie. But here's a question: Since when was a skinny man known for lavender silk shirts, who managed to pull off sickly romantic duos with both Kylie Minogue and PJ Harvey, not always a vulnerable old soul?
It's not that there's no notable progression from Nick's earlier stuff. On The Lyre of Orpheus, the addictive frontman's lecherous turns of phrase give way to a more refined, less aggressive poetry. Compare: from "Alice wakes; it is morning; she is yawning" ("Watching Alice," 1988) to "It's up in the morning and on the downs; little white clouds like gamboling lambs; And I am breathless over you." In contrast to Abattoir's familiar, sometimes unbearable blocks of metal-heavy noise, Orpheus is driven by joggy rhythms and Celtic undertones, and the soaring voices of a gospel choir reach tones more joyous, more celebratory than said drug-addled luminary is known for.
But to my brand of Nick fan (if a sepia-toned poster existed, it'd be on my wall with a plum kiss on his egg-shaped head), it's peculiar to pretend these moments are anything but characteristic: wry, slightly sarcastic, and yes, "sensitive." The albums say everything Nick Cave was ever dragged, spittling and finger-pointing, onstage to say: "There she goes, my beautiful world; there she goes, my beautiful world; there she goes again."
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.