Seventy On Seventy: The 70 Best Bob Dylan Songs, A To Z (Part One Of Two)
About a year ago, I was putting a book about Bob Dylan to bed. Since I was looking at year's lead time, my plan was for Bob Dylan: Like a Complete Unknown (Yale) to be released on Dylan's 70th birthday, for obvious reasons. I learned early on at my grandfather's funeral the biblical significance of threescore years and ten. Add two thousand years and the development of modern medicine, and you could say that yesterday's threescore years and ten could be today's fourscore years and ten, give or take—in other words, in twenty years, Bob Dylan might very well be Betty White. Still, 70 is a mighty powerful benchmark, and it officially puts the baby boomers, Dylan's original and most fervent demo, on notice that they are either officially old or, with the aid of the Facebook equivalent of 2031, could help snag Dylan a Saturday Night Live hosting stint.
My editor, a man who was always right and made it seem fun, suggested something for what people in the book industry call the "back matter." I presented myself with a challenge: Would it be possible to take Dylan's 400-plus songs and whittle them down to an age-appropriate list of 70? It seemed absurd. Listmaking was for people with OCD, or for VH1, or for Rolling Stone, whose coffee-table books about The 500 Greatest Songs of All Time always seem to assume time started in 1955. (This even though before 1955, there were songs by Mozart, Schubert, Beethoven, Wagner, George and Ira Gershwin, Duke Ellington, Kern, and Porter; that's not even taking into account the great songs before notation that are stuck in the Norton Anthology, which is of course a different kind of listmaking.) An issue devoted to 500 songs before time began would be quite a list indeed.
So I liked the number 70, and could even go through the painstaking work of separating the wheat from the chaff. But what seemed unimaginable to me was to actually rank the songs. How could one make an empirical case about whether "Like a Rolling Stone" was better than "Just Like a Woman" or "Tangled Up In Blue"? All these songs are perfect for what they are, a bliss that defies hierarchy. (Albums are different, since they are collections of songs. I say this because—full disclosure—nerve.com asked me to rank Dylan's albums, and it seemed just wrong to say no to them.) And so just a few weeks ago, on the Upper West Side I saw the Rolling Stone cover boasting that the 70 Greatest Dylan Songs (they should have added Of All Time!) were listed within. Did someone in Jann's Kremlin of Rock Taste take a look at the galleys my publisher sent their way? Or do people who love Bob just love playing with his age?
Of course, the No. 1 song on the RS list has the magazine's name in its title. The person who wrote on the top songs in the septalogue was Bono. Most of the entries came from a masked and anonymous committee (including extremely judicious and impressive people, one of whom generously blurbed my book), but the named bylines included Mick, Keith, Lucinda, and... I'm going to stop advertising it right now. I guess we're all in this together. But see my A-L just for what it is: A collection of half of his indisputable songs, some of which matched those selected by Rolling Stone, and some of which did not. (The rest of the alphabetical listing will be published tomorrow, on Dylan's actual birthday.) I only included Bob at his Best, but "Best" cannot be covered in 70 songs. This list will need a bootleg series, perhaps in future editions of the book, when the number 70 will be just an age that Dylan passed before he was really getting started.
(A guide for the perplexed: I have listed what I believe to be the definitive version, and then added alternate versions still worthy of mention in parentheses. Disagree? May a thousand flowers bloom.)
1. A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall Freewheelin' Bob Dylan (Live 1975)
2. Abandoned Love Golden Unplugged Album (Biograph)
3. Ain't Talkin' Modern Times (Tell Tale Signs)
4. All Along the Watchtower John Wesley Harding (Before the Flood)
5. Ballad of a Thin Man Highway 61 Revisited (Live 1966)
6. Blind Willie McTell Bootleg Series, Vol 1 (Outfidel Intakes)
7. Blowin' in the Wind Freewheelin' Bob Dylan
8. Crash On the Levee (Down in the Flood) Greatest Hits Vol. 2 (Genuine Basement Tapes)
9. Desolation Row Highway 61 Revisited (No Direction Home soundtrack)
10. Don't Think Twice, It's Alright Freewheelin' Bob Dylan
11. Every Grain of Sand Shot of Love (Bootleg Series)
12. Forever Young Planet Waves (Biograph; The Last Waltz)
13. Gates of Eden Bringing it All Back Home
14. Girl from the North Country Freewheelin' Bob Dylan (Nashville Skyline)
15. Groom's Still Waiting At the Altar Shot of Love
16. High Water (For Charley Patton) "Love and Theft"
17. I Shall Be Released Greatest Hits, Vol. 2 (Bootleg Series)
18. I Want You Blonde on Blonde
19. Idiot Wind Bootleg Series (Blood on the Tracks; Hard Rain)
20. Isis (with Jacques Levy) Desire (Biograph)
21. It Ain't Me, Babe Another Side of Bob Dylan
22. It Takes a Lot to Laugh, It Takes a Train to Cry Highway 61 Revisited
23. It's All Over Now, Baby Blue Bringing it all Back Home
24. It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding) Bringing it all Back Home
25. Jokerman Infidels (Late Night With David Letterman rehearsal and performance)
26. Just Like a Woman Blonde on Blonde (Live 1966)
27. Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues Highway 61 Revisited (Live 1966)
28. Lay, Lady, Lay Nashville Skyline
29. Like a Rolling Stone Highway 61 Revisited (Bootleg Series; Live 1966; Self Portrait)
30. Love Minus Zero/No Limit Bringing it all Back Home
(Part two is here.)
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.