The Ecstasy, the Agony: Live Blogging the MTV VMAs
In honor of the 2009 MTV Video Music Awards, we've invited SOTC buddies and pop savants Sean Fennessey and Ryan Dombal to lend a certain wisdom and perspective to these sure-to-be completely dignified proceedings. Gentleman?
9:00pm Sean: We're coming to you live from one or two or seven places. Ryan, how do you feel? Ryan: It's kinda hot in here. 9:01pm Sean: Always, always about Madge. Even if it isn't. Ryan: I guess Madonna is going to die now. Sean: Pete Wentz is moved, though, so you know, good. Ryan: He's Twittering. Ryan: Holler at Brooke Shields. Sean: "The roar of the lynch mob is so loud you're convinced your voice can never be heard." Sean: Madonna is a werewolf. Ryan: Cue Sharpton. Sean: Taylor Lautner, let's get it.
9:07pm Sean: Would Chris Brown take back all the woman-beating if he knew he could get in on this MJ tribute? Ryan: Why isn't Ne-Yo, like, dancing up there? Sean: So this is just a series of anono-MJs dancing around? I can see this every Sunday in Union Square. Ryan: Of, as Madonna mentioned on the "internet." Sean: Internet? Never heard of it. Ryan: "Scream" is wildly underrated, btw. Sean: Totally agree. Janet came out of this MJ fiasco looking good, though. 9:14pm Ryan: Katy Perry's guitar hero avatar, ladies and gents. Sean: Does Joe Perry get paid for this or is he just a good guy? Ryan: I hope all the surprise collaborations are based on last name coincidences. Sean: Russell Brand is wearing tighter pants than Vivica A. Fox on club night. 9:20pm Ryan: Props to Gaga for her Phantom of the Disco getup / somehow stealing Beyonce's shot. Sean: In case you missed it, she brought Kermit the Frog as her date. They made out. Ryan: Gaga just saw Dark Crystal for the first time. Sean: me: Oh no @wale's enormous bow tie. Ryan: He's not supposed to interact w/ the host. Sean: So I imagine you scoped out all the winners that leaked this weekend? Ryan: WHAT?! Seam: Nothing is sacred. Sorry, bud. Ryan: How is Shakira not on the Twilight soundtrack? Sean: Taylor Swift wins Best Female, which, really America, good for you. Ryan: Taylor has to stop pretending that she's not a star. Sean: "I sing country music." Sad. Own it! Ryan: I'm really worried about Kanye. Sean: He's always better at being a good sport when not trying to be a good sport. Ryan: First Blueprint 3, now rehashing bad bits on defenseless millionaire 17-year-olds. Sean: This probably isn't the place for me to tell you how wrong you are on BP3. You gotta believe in Jay-Z, America! 9:26pm Sean: Technical difficulties, only 26 minutes in! Ryan: You think Kanye and Beyonce are buddies? Like is Matthew going to end his career now? 9:28pm Sean: Kanye once told me Beyoncé is "the greatest entertainer of her generation." Susan Boyle was mad aggy about it. Ryan: That hair is a rehash, too. I dunno. He's running out of ideas. Sean: Twitter is revolting against Ye. It's a swarm of hate. 9:34pm Sean: What happened to Russell Brand's sleeves? 9:37pm Sean: The interstitial video treatments have really devolved, by the way. They used be crazy. Now they suck. Sean: Green Day wins Best Rock Video. Ryan: Green Day is the ultimate "why not" VMA band circa 2009. Everyone else is busy type thing. Sean: Tre Cool looks like Jeff Daniels circa 'Something Wild.' Ryan: Beiber vs. Kanye! Sean: Apparently Taylor Swift will be performing underground. Ryan: Is she going to flash a hobo? Sean: Subway trains are so cool! Ryan: This reminds me of that time that guy pissed on me while belching "Time After Time" on the F. Ryan: And Travolta hijacks the train, great. Ryan: One of those times I wish Smell-O-Vision existed. Sean: Never have I long so deeply for the JoBros. No pause. Ryan: NYC rulz. Sean: That's what it was like when we saw Wilco at Radio City Music Hall. Ryan: Why go to NYC if you're just gonna turn it into a Paramount lot anyway? 9:44pm Sean: Seriously just checked to see how my fantasy football team is doing. So we're not off to a great start. 9:47pm Ryan: So: Big "Empire State" finale w/ Jay in the New Times Square? Tourists expunged, natch. Sean: I hope they make it out to Park Slope. The F is such a great line! Ryan: New York, baby! Ryan: Remember when we saw Gabe @ Bubbys? He can pull off a suit, though. Sean: Gabe Saporta and I once auditioned for a Fuse talking heads show together. He was wildly insensitive. 9:50pm Sean: It's Lady Gaga time. Ryan: Gaga has been to Bjork.com. Sean: Gaga from the waist down: Best evs? Ryan: Very WWF starlet. Sean: Never seen a pop star have sex with, then get stabbed by a piano. The VMAs! Ryan: So is that also a tribute to MJ? People realize "Leave Me Alone" exists, right? I think he had more to bitch about. 9:58pm Ryan: How can we adequately report what's going on with Kanye? Sean: Rumor has it Kanye has been banned from MTV for LIFE!!!! Sean: Pink tweeted he is "the biggest piece of shit on earth." My tweet: Cool haircut! Ryan: I heard Kanye isn't allowed to watch MTV anymore. Sean: Kanye just had both eyes gouged out by Dave Sirulnick. Ryan: All of his videos are being deleted from YouTube. His blog is 404'd. Sean: Kanye West officially does not exist. Ryan: He didn't produce "Takeover." Sean: OMG there is no more "Takeover." 10:02pm Sean: Wisin Y Yandel dilettante nomination. Sean: Britney still wins. Ryan: Nelly's Spanish album will not be as good as Shakira's English album. Ryan: Kid is in Britney's band! Ryan: Megan Fox is really trying to look like Octamom nowadays amirite?! Sean: I'm over Megan Fox. When she comes down a peg I'll be back on board. Sean: Dear Green Day, we already made jokes about you. Leave. Ryan: Kanye should've picked a better spot. Like now. Ryan: I'm pretty sure this song is about ear-tug highlights. Ryan: Tre Cool is thinking super fucking hard right now. Ryan: More reaction shots from hip-hop stars, plz. Ryan: This is the first time I've felt young in three months. Ryan: Where's Girl Talk when you need him. Sean: Bad news, Ryan. I booked Billie Joe and Co. to perform at my wedding. Sean: I wanted a real "rebellious" feel. Ryan: Yeah, Winger wasn't available, apparently. Ryan: Kanye Update: Blackberry deactivated his account. 10:16pm Ryan: Kristen Stewart now showing contempt for fanbase via haircut. Sean: It's for the Runaways movie, chill! Ryan: Twilight 2: New Movie, Same Headband Ryan: She hates the world, Sean. Ryan: Flying Fangz, Hidden Virginity Sean: Male lower abdomens are so hawt right now. 10:20pm Sean: Ilene and I just broke down how thin Beyoncé looks. Whaddya think of that for instant commentary!? Leggings! Ryan: Weird to see B w/o Fosse dancers at this point. Ryan: Spoke too soon. Ryan: Hate to say this is not an event a year later. Sean: At what point are we over the "Single Ladies" routine? Ryan: Kanye killed Beyoncé's career, basically. Ryan: That's the takeaway. Sean: This is the closest I'm ever going to get to B's crotch. 10:26pm Ryan: Holler @ Tiesto. Ryan: "Use Somebody" is officially the most covered song of 2009 w/ Solange redo. Sean: I'm so proud of Solange. She actually shifted the conversation. Ryan: So are we blaming Solange for Jay's Grizzly Bear infatuation? Sean: Obvs. Ryan: I used to like her. Ryan: When she was playing fake TV shows @ SXSW. Ryan: But she did more to ruin Jay than Jones. Sean: She's still great. She's influential now! 10:31pm Sean: Diddy says Kanye's name and the boos arrive. Astonishing. Ryan: People are super sensitive, and dumb. Ryan: At least Kanye has fodder for his next album-- now people actually hate him. "Hate" even kinda makes sense. Sean: And he made himself so easy to love! Sean: Gerard Butler=rock star Ryan: Butler is killing this Muse intro! Ryan: So did Spin know about this? Sean: I think the question is: Did America know about this? Sean: A band could not be less in tune with what makes for popular music in the U.S. right now than these guys. Ryan: Ok, so Thom Yorke won't be a good egg, so Industry gets Muse. Makes sense on paper, I suppose. Sean: Radiohead killed it at the Grammys. That was enough. Ryan: This was inevitable but...how the fuck does Muse get a shot and Paramore is nowhere to be found. Sean: Where are these nubile young girls who worship Muse? Were they airmailed in from Wales? Ryan: It's a glorified video shoot. Maybe this is an Activision move. Sean: The whole walk-around-and-rock-thing needs a facelift. Tommy Lee was playing drums upside down 20 years ago! Ryan: Muse GH is probably the best way to experience them. Sean: Have you played "Knights of Cydonia" on Hard? That shit is tough! Ryan: I bet. Ryan: I like the idea that bands are geting signed now based on their GH-ability. 10:45pm Ryan: Taylor Update: She just downloaded that app that tells you where to get off on the subway platform. 10:46pm Ryan: All American Rejects trying to be Of Montreal Sean: Wale is not amused Ryan: Emo is dead. me: J-Lo fresh out the cryogenic freezer, talking about the Bronx and "hip-hop." Ryan: Electro! Sean: Eminem is so electro. Ryan: I wish Jay kept the hair. Sean: Yeah, it was cute. Like when your son comes back from college with a goatee. Ryan: I was waiting for a Money Train ref from J-Lo. Bummer. Sean: Kid Cudi, paying tribute to DJ AM with the blowjob song. Makes sense. Ryan: Cudi is such an asshole. Ryan: Where is Kurt Loder, fuck Sean: Jim Cantiello is the anti-Loder. Sean: Un-Loder. Sean: He's de-Loder. Ryan: How long can it take to not think of an angle for his Where the Wild Things Are? MTV.com review. Ryan: I wonder what Tabitha Soren is up to... Sean: Rooming with Martha Quinn? Ryan: Adam Curry! And we're done. 10:54pm Ryan: Black Eyed Peas should perform "I Gotta Feeling" on this show. Just saying. Sean: Can't believe I'm delaying "Mad Men" for this. Zach, you owe me, dude. Sean: Trending topic tomorrow: Who is Asher Roth's girlfriend? Ryan: That's a downgrade for Kelis. 10:58pm Sean: Gaga, head to toe in blood red outfit and mask: Revolutionary. Ryan: I mean, no competition but speech of the night. Ryan: Even Serena wants to kill Kanye. Sean: She would annihilate him. 11:02pm Ryan: Pink's Club Med vaca pays off. Sean: If Pink didn't have a nipple slip, would that be the biggest surprise of the night? Sean: Doing trapeze=The new interrupting Taylor Swift. 11:07pm Sean: Robert Loggia's big comeback in the Mac/PC commercial is the best. Sean: They shoulda had him play "Heart & Soul" on the giant foot keyboard, tho. 11:10pm Ryan: Have you tried 5 Gum? Sean: True Story: I had 150 packs in my old VIBE office. Sean: When it launched they sent me a box. Sean It's a Wrigley's product. Ryan: Wow. Where is it now? Sean: Buried 6 feet deep along with my career. 11:11pm Ryan: "Wale, we need you to stretch" -- the six most depressing words in awards show history. Sean: "Our generation's David Letterman: Jimmy Fallon." *dead* Ryan: Letterman never put his dick in a box. Sean: Just his soul. Ryan: Deep. Sean: Beyoncé wins Video of the Year. And the clowns wept. Sean: Kanye West lives! Sean: Oh wait, Taylor's coming out to have her moment. Kanye's dead again! Ryan: I knew it was planned! Ryan: Yr crazy for this one Kanye. Sean: You a genius! Ryan: Perez is crying. 11:18pm Ryan: Sad how little Kanye needs to do the be the story nowadays. Sean: Every year we complain about this show, but every year he does something interesting. 11:22pm Ryan: Katy Perry should've done "Hot N Cold" / Shakira should've done "She Wolf" #whymtvcantaffordtimessquare Ryan: This is not that hard, people. Ryan: Jay needs to mention Kanye here. Sean: Never gonna happen. Ryan: Shame. Ryan: Aggro flow is so unnecessary. Sean: Disagree! Ryan: Em loves it. Sean: "Still sippin' mai tais" - so true! Ryan: Alicia's one-hoop look: by choice? Ryan: This song is way more censorable than I originally thought. Sean: Because it's got heart! Sean: I love Jay-Z, I'm sorry. Sean: Don't dance too close to Alicia, Beyoncé is watching. Ryan: Lil Mama = Soy Bomb 2009 Or whoever that was. 11:29pm Sean: "This Is It" is the crassest shit ever. Ryan: MJ killed MTV. Sean: "Look, Michael is normal cuz he works just like you, also he made 'Thriller.' 'Thriller.'" Ryan: Russell Brand de-fanged is so pointless. 11:35pm Sean: If you have gotten this far, welcome to the kill screen. Ryan: Going off my theory that Kanye sabotaged Blueprint 3-- Jay realized this and made him do the asshole thing to get people back on Jay's side b/c there's no alternative. Sean: You solved it. Ryan: Yes! Ryan: Grammys already booking Taylor Swift / Kanye mashup performance. Sean: Obama beer meeting? 11:39pm Ryan: Biggest Winner: Rihanna, for not showing up Sean: Best moment? Ryan: I'm going to say Pink copying Kanye's heart-on-chest thing from last year. Sean: I enjoyed the cutaways to Beyonce all night. Sean: "I'm shocked!" Sean: "I'm happy" Sean: "I'm proud" Sean: "I'm rich" Ryan: Beyonce is very expressive. I wish Stringer was Jay's seat-filler. Sean: He was busy with Ali Larter. 11:43pm Ryan: You think Beyonce respects Gaga? Sean: I think she's either afraid of her or sort of amused. "Oh that's nice, crazy white lady." Ryan: I think Beyonce's afraid of Rihanna, which is why she wasn't there. Sean: I think Rihanna's waiting to make an insane T.V. event comeback, which will be great. Ryan: Yeah, I hope so. Trent Reznor should produce her album. Sean: Watching this MJ tribute again, it's just as lackluster as anything BET did. Ryan: Timberlake couldn't be bothered to plug his fashion line? Come on. Ryan: What happened to the Vanguard award, btw? Ryan: That was usually a pretty good look. Spike, Hype, etc. Sean: Where is: Usher, Whitney Houston, Wayne, etc.? Ryan: Drake is rehabbing? Sean: Seems like a great place to end! Drake, we love you!
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.