|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
City Gourmet
Win an Office Party from City Gourmet Eatery!
Latino Poets Society
Enter for your chance to win tickets to The Latino Poet’s Society Spoken Word Tour at The Cherry Lane Theater in Greenwich Village!
Jammin' with Jazz at Lincoln Center
Win admission for two to one performance at Dizzy's Club Coca-Cola, New York’s hottest jazz club, plus a collection of jazz CDs and more!
Bash'd
Enter to win tickets to a performance of Bash'd: A Gay Rap Opera! |
write a comment
show/hide comments (1)
RB on Sun Sep 23, 2007, 22:53, says:
This article offers a obviously biased view about treatments for the mentally ill. I am one of the
"guinea pigs" currently volunteering for Trans-magnetic Stimulation (TMS) for OCD (Obsessive
Compulsive Disorder) at New York Presbyterian. I feel the author plays up the shock value (pardon
the pun) of using electricity to alter the brain. I couldn't really describe the treatment as
"painful"; the worst part of my nearly 8 weeks in the study has been the difficulty of having to
stay awake during the procedures. Even the woman quoted in the article who thought the treatments to
be painful when she started goes on to say that they eventually became relaxing and put her to
sleep! There is hardly much if any pain involved in TMS, at least in my experience. The other
difficulty with doing this has been the time I need to take out to commute to the city every weekday
to go to the hospital, but if I do manage to gain some relief from my OCD it will all be very well
worth it. I don't see, however, that there has been any major improvements in my symptoms so far and
this story tells of how some patients may feel discouraged if the treatment doesn't work, leading to
a worsening of their condition. While they are referring here to depression, not OCD, I see there is
no mention of how these treatments may help people with mental illness indirectly- not by any change
in brain circuitry by means electrical impulse, but simply by providing them a place to go, a
supportive environment around people, as often is the case where the depressed individual becomes
very isolated. While many people with depression might not see that anything can be gained through
psychotherapy and be reluctant to attend, they might have belief in something "more scientific", and
inadvertently benefit from the human interaction and direction in participating in something.
Especially something seemly without side effects like those of psychiatric medications. Though due
caution must exercised to modify such statements, adding that focal brain stimulation is very new,
techniques are still in development and long term hazards still unknown (as is the case with
virtually any novel remedy.) But to me it appears like the researchers at Columbia try to take every
precaution possible to guard patients from harm, always asking about adverse effects and recording
any imaginable discomfort- for example, neck pain from having to hold your head still for too long.
TMS is very different from ECT, which is also discussed in the story. But even the risks of ECT are
not portrayed quite accurately. The woman in this article suffered profound, lasting loss of her
memory but this side effect is not always permanent and the statistics on it's rate are
controversial. To summarize, I feel that this article was written in a way that dramatized the
experience of undergoing these types of treatments in order to attract the reader's interest, or
other words, make the subject more "stimulating".
|
Free classifieds New York City
|
||||||||||||||||||||||