village voice
RSS/Podcast feed for Village Voice News Status Ain't Hood
The All-Dirty Edition
Popped! Music Festival
Enter to win a trip to this year’s 3-day POPPED! Music festival in the Philadelphia, June 20-22nd!
Vlada Lounge
Enter to win a $50 gift certificate to Vlada Lounge!
Alice Smith
Enter to win tickets to see Alice Smith on Thursday, May 22nd at the Highline Ballroom!
SoHo Stroll 2008
Enter to win a SoHo Stroll 2008 broom signed by James Blunt and designed and decorated by the New York Academy of Art!
Elia Salon
Enter to Win A Hair Package Special by the BEST DOMINICAN SALON for you & a friend!
Lit Lounge
Enter for complimentary admission to see Power Solo from Denmark with Band Antenna, Sea That Dried Up, and Chem Trail at Lit Lounge!
United Artists
Enter to win a 90th Anniversary United Artists DVD prize package!
Iron & Silk
Enter to win 5 personal training sessions at Iron & Silk Fitness!
News
Rudy's Ties to a Terror Sheikh
Giuliani's business contracts tie him to the man who let 9/11's mastermind escape the FBI
by Wayne Barrett
November 20th, 2007 12:00 AM
Illustration by Wes Duvall
Special reporting by Samuel Rubenfeld and additional research by Adrienne Gaffney and Danielle Schiffman
Three weeks after 9/11, when the roar of fighter jets still haunted the city's skyline, the emir of gas-rich Qatar, Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifah al-Thani, toured Ground Zero. Although a member of the emir's own royal family had harbored the man who would later be identified as the mastermind of the attack—a man named Khalid Sheikh Muhammad, often referred to in intelligence circles by his initials, KSM—al-Thani rushed to New York in its aftermath, offering to make a $3 million donation, principally to the families of its victims. Rudy Giuliani, apparently unaware of what the FBI and CIA had long known about Qatari links to Al Qaeda, appeared on CNN with al-Thani that night and vouched for the emir when Larry King asked the mayor: "You are a friend of his, are you not?"

"We had a very good meeting yesterday. Very good," said Giuliani, adding that he was "very, very grateful" for al-Thani's generosity. It was no cinch, of course, that Giuliani would take the money: A week later, he famously rejected a $10 million donation from a Saudi prince who advised America that it should "adopt a more balanced stand toward the Palestinian cause." (Giuliani continues to congratulate himself for that snub on the campaign trail.) Al-Thani waited a month before expressing essentially the same feelings when he returned to New York for a meeting of the U.N. General Assembly and stressed how important it was to "distinguish" between the "phenomenon" of 9/11 and "the legitimate struggles" of the Palestinians "to get rid of the yoke of illegitimate occupation and subjugation." Al-Thani then accused Israel of "state terrorism" against the Palestinians.

But there was another reason to think twice about accepting al-Thani's generosity that Giuliani had to have been aware of, even as he heaped praise on the emir. Al Jazeera, the Arabic news network based in Qatar (pronounced "Cutter"), had been all but created by al-Thani, who was its largest shareholder. The Bush administration was so upset with the coverage of Osama bin Laden's pronouncements and the U.S. threats to bomb Afghanistan that Secretary of State Colin Powell met the emir just hours before Giuliani's on-air endorsement and asked him to tone down the state-subsidized channel's Islamist footage and rhetoric. The six-foot-eight, 350-pound al-Thani, who was pumping about $30 million a year into Al Jazeera at the time, refused Powell's request, citing the need for "a free and credible media." The administration's burgeoning distaste for what it would later brand "Terror TV" was already so palpable that King—hardly a newsman—asked the emir if he would help "spread the word" that the U.S. was "not targeting the average Afghan citizen." Al-Thani ignored the question—right before Giuliani rushed in to praise him again.

In retrospect, Giuliani's embrace of the emir appears peculiar. But it was only a sign of bigger things to come: the launching of a cozy business relationship with terrorist-tolerant Qatar that is inconsistent with the core message of Giuliani's current presidential campaign, namely that his experience and toughness uniquely equip him to protect America from what he tauntingly calls "Islamic terrorists"—an enemy that he always portrays himself as ready to confront, and the Democrats as ready to accommodate.

The contradictory and stunning reality is that Giuliani Partners, the consulting company that has made Giuliani rich, feasts at the Qatar trough, doing business with the ministry run by the very member of the royal family identified in news and government reports as having concealed KSM—the terrorist mastermind who wired funds from Qatar to his nephew Ramzi Yousef prior to the 1993 bombing of the World Trade Center, and who also sold the idea of a plane attack on the towers to Osama bin Laden—on his Qatar farm in the mid-1990s.

This royal family member is Abdallah bin Khalid al-Thani, Qatar's minister of Islamic affairs at the time, who was later installed at the interior ministry in January 2001 and reappointed by the emir during a government shake-up earlier this year. Abdallah al-Thani is also said to have welcomed Osama bin Laden on two visits to the farm, a charge repeated as recently as October 10, 2007, in a Congressional Research Service study. Abdallah al-Thani's interior ministry or the state-owned company it helps oversee, Qatar Petroleum, has worked with Giuliani Security & Safety LLC, a subsidiary of Giuliani Partners, on an undisclosed number of contracts, the value of which neither the government nor the company will release. But there's little question that a security agreement with Qatar's government, or with Qatar Petroleum, would put a company like Giuliani's in direct contact with the ministry run by Abdallah al-Thani: The website of Qatar's government, and the interior ministry's press office, as well as numerous press stories, all confirm that the ministry controls a 2,500-member police force, the General Administration of Public Security, and the Mubahathat, or secret police. The ministry's charge under law is to "create and institute security in this country." Hassan Sidibe, a public-relations officer for the ministry, says that "a company that does security work, they have to get permission from the interior ministry."

What's most shocking is that Abdallah al-Thani has been widely accused of helping to spirit KSM out of Qatar in 1996, just as the FBI was closing in on him. Robert Baer, a former CIA supervisor in the region, contends in a 2003 memoir that the emir himself actually sanctioned tipping KSM. The staff of the 9/11 Commission, meanwhile, noted that the FBI and CIA "were reluctant to seek help from the Qatari government" in the arrest of KSM, "fearing that he might be tipped off." When Qatar's emir was finally "asked for his help" in January 1996, Qatari authorities "first reported that KSM was under surveillance," then "asked for an alternative plan that would conceal their aid to Americans," and finally "reported that KSM had disappeared." Continue

More by Wayne Barrett
Hillary and the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy
The strange case of conservative pundits and their love for Barack Obama

We Come to Bury Rudy
The evil that men do lives after their mayoral stints—and even 9/11

Delegating Authority
As McCain and Romney fight for the nomination, New York’s G.O.P. has a lot to lose

Who Built Rudy's House in the Hamptons?
Giuliani's contractor might not have had a 'hire standard' on illegal labor

Giuliani's Immigration Problem
Much as he hates to admit it, Rudy loved (most of) those huddled masses

Add a Comment

Not ? Login as a different user.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By submitting a comment, you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms of Use.

Login or Register

Login or register to have a chance to win Free Stuff, subscribe to newsletters and much more!

Login Register
helen on Wed Dec 5, 2007, 07:22, says:
Ben Brodsky:

This story has been unfortunately picked up on by the media. Unfortunately, because it's festering with rancid lies and fabrication and seems to have been written by a hack journalist. As the previous post states, Qatar and the al-Thani family have normalized and peaceful relations with Israel and they have never supported terrorism. I am really no lover of Guiliani but would rather condemn him based on truth, not on lies.
chudzikiewiczherbchodkiewicz@yah on Sun Dec 2, 2007, 15:40, says:
Wayne Barrett has a habit of taking information, ignoring the most important pieces of information, and making black look like white and white look like black. The Emirs of Qatar and the al-Thani family are well-known for their support of Peace with Israel, in the past abandoning the Arab Boycott of Israel, and, to be blunt, not discrimminating against Jewish businessmen or Jewish companies or companies with Israeli affiliates. They have supported ending the Asian banning of Israel in regional sports. They have never supported terrorism.

To have Wayne Barrett totally mis-represent Qatar, the al-Thani dynasty, and, yes, Rudi Guiliani's terrorism record is just plain DUMB. I voted for Gore and Kerry and expect to vote for Hiliary Clinton for president, but slandering and smearing Rudi Guiliani really doesn't speak well for the Village Voice or Mr. Barrett. This is the second or third time people I have some knowledge of have been maligned by Mr. Barrett carefully leaving out basic facts and blowing up minor ones. I guess he never has gotten over Ruth Messinger never becoming Mayor and the total failure of David Dinkins as Mayor.
Ben Brodsky on Fri Nov 30, 2007, 02:15, says:
paul, i think u missed the point.

Rudy claims these people are bad, yet provides security for them? makes his money off them? hypocracy runs through Rudy's blood... shipping the homeless to other cities does not count as reducing the homeless population in a real world, but in Rudy's, it does
Paul on Thu Nov 29, 2007, 23:10, says:
Very impartial reporting Im sorry to say! Have we all gone mad? Is that not the same country that hosts the largest U.S.airforce base in the Middle East and who reported years ago to the FBI that it had Osama at Doha International airport and did they want him? Is that not the country whos TV station (AlJazzera)was threatened to be bombed by US warplanes from its own soil last year? and is that not the country on whos soil a patriot missile was launched and self destructed from a US airforce base last month? (what really happened.com)Im sorry to have to say this but lets try to keep things sensible if we want to keep our allies in the complex and difficult arena that the Middle East is.
lydia on Thu Nov 29, 2007, 20:21, says:
After hearing about this, I eagerly awaited the morning news. NOTHING. Not a word was mentioned in our local Palm Beach Post. I am so frustrated with the media.
claudialong on Thu Nov 29, 2007, 11:28, says:
Hey Wayne! Remember?

Good story. I just wish to God a few major media outlets would pick up on this kind of stuff. The political coverage just makes my head explode... is America composed entirely of kindergartners?

And that UTube debate... god help us.
Ben Brodsky on Thu Nov 29, 2007, 00:47, says:
will this story catch on through the whole media or will that hamptons scandal be all the masses get to hear?

The Village Voice Ad Index
The Village Voice Summer Guide 2008

» click here to see more...

The Village Voice Summer 2008 Education Supplement

» click here to see more...

The Village Voice Spring Arts Supplement

» click here to see more...