village voice
RSS/Podcast feed for Village Voice News Status Ain't Hood
Pine-Sol Lookin' Boy
Saints, Sinners, Obsession, and Seduction
Enter to win a Jennifer Jones and Charles Boyer Film Society of Lincoln Center series pass!
Lit Lounge
Enter for complimentary admission to see Power Solo from Denmark with Band Antenna, Sea That Dried Up, and Chem Trail at Lit Lounge!
Rasputin
Enter to win dinner and drinks for two at Rasputin Restaurant and Cabaret!
DeVotchKa
Enter to win tickets to see DeVotchKa on Tuesday, May 20th at Terminal 5!
United Artists
Enter to win a 90th Anniversary United Artists DVD prize package!
Iron & Silk
Enter to win 5 personal training sessions at Iron & Silk Fitness!
News
For Some Black Parents, the New Home Room is Home
Public schools are failing black boys, say a growing number of parents who are homeschooling
by Chloe A. Hilliard
April 8th, 2008 12:00 AM

Deion Terry Rhoden, P. Aurora Robinson and her son Tau Issa Robinson-Farrar holding class in Bread-Stuy, a Beford Stuyvesant café.
Stacy Kranitz

Say "homeschooling" and what tends to come to mind are the whitest people you know, holding Sunday school every day of the week in their basements, producing kids who can declaim against Charles Darwin for hours on end, but who are so screwed up socially that you can't imagine them getting a date, except years later as part of a group outing to Christian Day at Disney World.

So, with that admittedly over-broad stereotype in mind, it's something of a shock to see the lessons in progress at Bread Stuy, a small café in Brooklyn, where customers sip at their coffee and read newspapers, unaware that a woman named P. Aurora Robinson is holding a homeschooling class in their midst.

Her two teenagers, working at laptops, are tapping away at their writing assignments for the day. They're a little young for coffeehouse literary types, but otherwise look the part: Deion in a baseball cap, Tau wearing his hair in twists, both hunched over their screens, glasses resting on the tips of their noses. They're slender, studious, and seriously into their work.

And they're black.

Robinson, like a small but growing number of black parents, has chosen to take her son Tau out of the public-school system and teach him on her own (Deion is a cousin's child she's also teaching).

In the 2006–2007 school year, the city's Department of Education says that 3,654 students in New York were homeschooled. Most are white, but a growing number are African-American. Black parents tend to take their children out of the schools for other than religious reasons, and homeschooling groups say black children taught at home are nearly always boys. Like Robinson, some of New York's parents have concluded that the school system is failing the city's black boys, and have elected to teach them at home as an alternative.

Robinson's motives were even more specific: She wanted to cushion Tau from the serious culture shock of moving from rural Missouri to her hometown of Brooklyn.

She had been teaching in Springfield, Missouri, as a professor of architecture at Drury College, the only black member of the architecture faculty. Her son, meanwhile, was teased in the usual way for being one of the few black students in a white school. Tau says he had to explain to his teachers and fellow students that just because he was black didn't mean that he was from "the 'hood."

"Somehow, he was supposed to serve them better if he was more ghetto," says his mother. "We were out there on our own in the badlands."

Continue
More by Chloe A. Hilliard
The Fabolous Life
Hanging with a rapper who has close ties to his home. Maybe too close.

Shooting Star
Taking aim at Remy Ma

Hot Ghetto BET
Does a black television network have a responsibility to do better?

A Murder Invisible
A young woman dies at the hands of her boyfriend—no, not the one you heard about

Seoul Train
A Korean pop mogul with a thing for Berry Gordy has invaded New York, and he's brought a stable of potential stars with him

Add a Comment

Not ? Login as a different user.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By submitting a comment, you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms of Use.

Login or Register

Login or register to have a chance to win Free Stuff, subscribe to newsletters and much more!

Login Register
momtrek on Thu Apr 17, 2008, 11:48, says:
"A state appellate judge found that in order to teach at home, a parent needs to have the same credentials as a teacher at a public or private school. And not only would parents need a teaching certificate, but they would also need to submit lesson plans to the state for approval."

I just wanted to correct your information; private school teachers in California are not required to have credentials and private schools are not required to submit their lesson plans to the state. Parents who wish to homeschool file a private school affidavit no different than the local parochial school. The rules that apply to them apply to homeschoolers; therefore no credential or submitted lesson plans. If the judge's ruling is allowed to stand (it has been vacated pending another hearing) it will apply to all schools, private and public, including all teachers teaching "out of field"; history teachers teaching science, science teacher teaching language arts, etc. It would be an unmitigated disaster for the state of California, which is why the education department seems to have taken the side of homeschooling families.
David McElroy on Wed Apr 16, 2008, 15:13, says:
The lead of this article is one of the most prejudiced pieces of journalism I've ever read. It reveals a mindset that makes tremendously biased assumptions which aren't based on reality. Did you even bother to learn the reality of homeschooled kids nationally or did you just rely on the stereotypes perpetrated by those who worship at the altar of government schools?

For you to say that "homeschooling" brings those things to mind is just as prejudiced and just as bad as someone to connects black people or Jews to stupid and inaccurate stereotypes. It's not just the fact that you wrote them. It's that you actually believe them.

Homeschooling is done by many, many people for a variety of reasons, some for religious reasons, but even MORE for reasons involving the utter failure of government-run schools. For you to repeat these blatantly offensive stereotypes is no different from writing a story that associates black people with watermelons or Jews with greed.

Start living up to real liberal thinking and quit using stereotypes. This particular one is offensive and wrong. It contributes to a further misunderstanding of why people make the choices that they do to get away from failed government-run schools.
meades on Tue Apr 15, 2008, 15:34, says:
I also homeschooled my son during his middle school years. We took him out of school, followed all the guidelines, etc. and we had absolutely NO help! My husband works from home which worked good for us. My son did his school work from curriculum ordered online, worksheets from various internet homeschool sites--this is where we got ALL our homeschool information! I went over the work in the evenings and planned his work for the next day. He also went to the library and did other outside activities with his friends. As a matter of fact, he met all the friends he has now (he's 19 now) at the library! I worked at a major university at that time and found him a music tutor and a math tutor. And, my cousin was a teacher so we had to have her look over his work and sign off on a form saying all his work was up to par. BUT...when it came time to show all his work to the high school (he wanted to go to high school so we let him continue on to high school-which is important to young kids). BUT.. when it came time for him to graduate with the rest of his class, our very poor school system (which is in Cleveland, OH) would not even recognize all the work he did and my son had to spend another year in high school!!! We are in one of the worse school systems in America and they continue to be in the top 10 of the worst school systems!! We put new windows in our schools and then we tear them down!!! Now you tell me...WTF??? Anyway, he'll be out very, very soon (thank you, Lord!!). I am truly glad to hear a positive story about homeschooling especially with Black children!! I am very glad it's working for them!!! Believe me, and I know you see it too, your children will be smarter than those who've gone through the public schools because they are learning more when being homeschooled. Not just a set curriculum that's more than likely not correct! I'm happy for this family and other families who teach their own children!! Good Luck!!!

The Village Voice Ad Index
The Village Voice Summer 2008 Education Supplement

» click here to see more...

The Village Voice Spring Arts Supplement

» click here to see more...