Nude vegetarian communists haven't occupied the stretch of shoreline on Staten Island known as the Spanish Camp for decades now. But that doesn't mean that the slice of land fronting Raritan Bay is without controversy. To the contrary, the spot is in tumult as dozens of families are being evicted from cottages they have owned, some for 40 years.
That's because the 17-acre site on which the homes sit is being sold by the Spanish Naturopath Society (SNS), which founded the camp in the 1920s. Developer John DiScala plans to replace the 80 or so bungalows with 37 megamansions, and will close on the deal when the land is vacant; he says he expects to break ground in June. Residents have lost a string of court battles to preserve their homes and are being evicted; fewer than a dozen remain. By summer, the Spanish Camp will be home to no one.
"We supported the Spanish Naturopath Society for all these years, and now they're giving us the boot," says John Colón, a 40-year-old police officer who has lived in Spanish Camp for 33 years. "We have no options left."
The rise of the Spanish Camp was as idiosyncratic as its demise. It was established as a summer refuge for Spaniards living in New York, many of whom were leftists who had fled Franco and were looking for a place to follow their vegetarian regime, swim nude in segregated sessions, and exercise outdoors. Eventually, the camp evolved into an informal community of fully clothed, nonpartisan omnivores who were not SNS members but who paid the society rent now between $100 and $400 a month for land on which they live in bungalows they own.
New York Knicks vs. Memphis Grizzlies
TicketsSat., Oct. 29, 7:30pm
New York Rangers vs. Tampa Bay Lightning
TicketsSun., Oct. 30, 7:00pm
St. John's Red Storm Men's Basketball vs. Baruch College Bearcats Men's Basketball
TicketsMon., Oct. 31, 7:00pm
Brooklyn Nets vs. Chicago Bulls
TicketsMon., Oct. 31, 7:30pm
In 1997, the SNS decided to sell the land to DiScala for a reported $7 million. Last September, civil court judge Philip Straniere dismissed claims by residents including retirees, police officers, and city workers that they believed the land would never be sold. Straniere ordered residents to move by February 8 this year; some linger on extensions.
Residents are not only losing their homes; barring a lawsuit that could take years to decide, they will not be compensated for their bungalows. Paschal Corbo, attorney for SNS, says owners are free to haul their homes away a proposal even he admits is limited to legal, not practical, considerations. "It's absolutely disengenuous," says Tom Shanahan, who works for Public Advocate Mark Green and who has been trying to preserve the camp. "Where in New York City would you move them? How would you move them? This isn't an option, and everybody knows that."
Standing to gain are the society's 52 members, most of whom do not live at Spanish Camp. Corbo says they will divide the proceeds of the sale among themselves, then dissolve the nonprofit society, ending a once thriving club that was incorporated 70 years ago. Originally, the SNS rented the bayfront strip and erected tents on the beach and in the woods. SNS members installed a common latrine, and built a grocery and a salon. Eventually, people constructed summer cottages, and in 1948, the SNS bought the land with money from its members for about $50,000, Corbo says.
Around the same time, SNS stopped taking on new members. But it let people, including nonmembers, build or buy bungalows on SNS land. Over the years, they became year-round homes, and the camp grew into a community surrounded by old-growth trees, nestled along the ocean shore and the side of a freshwater lake, and home to herons, egrets, and rare sea grasses. It was such a setting that lured Dorothy Day who founded the Catholic Worker, devoted her life to the poor, and is now a possible candidate for sainthood to retire to a Spanish Camp cottage, where she lived until her death in 1980.
Spanish Camp's environment seems worlds away from the city beyond, and in a bureau- cratic sense, it is a phantom community. None of the bungalows are legally accounted for; not a single one has an occupancy permit required by the city's building department. Even so, the force of law has made itself known in these past weeks. "There's a city marshal coming in here every day locking people out," says resident Dee Vandenburg, who has lived in her oceanfront cottage for 10 years. "That is very real."
The marshals are making way for Central Park East Estates, a development the 46-year-old DiScala has named in honor of the trees he intends to spare. Custom-built, 4000-square-foot homes will start at $929,000 and top out at $1.8 million. Says DiScala, "I want to do something beautiful here."
Camp residents say DiScala's plan can only ruin natural beauty, noting that the site includes wetlands, tidal inlets, and designated open space. "We have thousands of ducks here; we have old rare trees," says resident Colón, who remembers clamming and fishing for porgies in the bay. "We're on the Atlantic flyway and get all kinds of birds, all sorts of things that could be damaged."
Development has so overtaken Staten Island's shoreline that Spanish Camp is a rare rustic spot. "There's a total disregard for the environment in this whole island," says Vandenburg. "You just pour concrete, put up pink brick and gold fixtures, and that's it. Maybe you get a $10,000 fine for building in a wetland, but you sold a million-dollar home. It's the cost of doing business."
DiScala's applications to build are under review at the state environmental agency, and he awaits approval from various city offices. And DiScala has not formally closed the deal to buy the land. But he is running full-page, four-color ads in The Staten Island Advance claiming that Central Park East is 60 percent sold.
DiScala himself is a man of many hats. While he chairs the boards of 11 companies, state tax officials say DiScala owes $7275.87 in personal income taxes. He filed for bankruptcy in 1992; that case was closed in 1995. His businesses include a wetlands consulting firm, an outfit called Richmond Magazine, and Hell's Kitchen Casting Corp. "In the next few years, we're gonna make movies," says DiScala, whose family lived in Hell's Kitchen 40 years ago.
Another DiScala firm is a publishing company called Boys in Blue Productions. Has it published anything? "No, not yet," says DiScala, seemingly forgetting its 1997 adventure, New York's Sixth Family, a screed by former transit cop union head Ron Reale, who was convicted of conspiracy, racketeering, witness tampering, and wire fraud. In the book, Reale depicts Mayor Rudy Giuliani and his administration as an- other version of the city's five crime families.
Camp residents are making a last-ditch effort to landmark several cottages Dorothy Day was associated with, and perhaps a whole row of bungalows approaching the water. Shoehorning the shacks among the mansions would be a testament to the history not only of the camp, but of Staten Island, which, as Corbo rightly notes, is not exactly a vacation destination anymore. "The houses they want to put in are going to be real big," says Corbo. "They're going to be a statement."
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.