How Chuck Schumer's New Legislation Equates Climbing a Bridge to These Violent Crimes
Don't try to get any closer to this stunning view.
Photo Credit: Compfight
This week, Senator Charles Schumer proposed making trespassing on "critical infrastructure" -- bridges, buildings, and the like -- a federal offense, punishable by up to five years in prison.
He pointed to the pair of German artists who this summer allegedly scaled the Brooklyn Bridge and replaced its American flags with white flags; a Russian tourist who climbed a bridge to take a selfie; and a teen who somehow made it to the top of 1 World Trade Center.
"We cannot allow New York City infrastructure to be turned into playgrounds -- or worse," Schumer said.
Absolutely not! When you let the city become a wholesome nexus of childhood fun, the terrorists win!
It was a move Kumar Rao, an attorney with legal-services nonprofit Bronx Defenders, called excessive. "If the purpose is to deter pranksters and protesters that have made a splash recently, then the law is clearly unduly harsh for the behavior at issue, and absolutely triggers First Amendment concerns," he writes in an email. "Five years(!) for hanging a banner or flag on a bridge puts it on par with many violent felonies."
Just how violent are we talking? Take a look at some heinous crimes that have taken place around the country that have netted the perpetrators five years in prison:
- There's Frankie Haywood Jr., the Kalamazoo, Michigan, man who was sentenced to five years after being convicted of holding his girlfriend against her will in his apartment and torturing her for more than 24 hours. When police arrived, he threatened to shoot them.
- In Daytona Beach, Florida, James Grey Bull, 62, got his five-year sentence just last month after pleading guilty to raping his eight-month-old pit bull puppy.
- After her children were repeatedly burned, bruised, and gagged in a pattern of systematic torture, Massachusetts resident Silvania Santiago was sentenced to five years for "permitting assault and battery on a child with injury" and "two counts of reckless endangerment of a child." Police suspected a man who had been living with Santiago of the abuse. But she blamed the child's injuries on falling ceiling tiles, burns from touching a hot radiator, and frostbite from eating a Popsicle -- even after she pleaded guilty to the charges.
- Twenty-two-year-old Alexander Roscoli in Emmaus, Pennsylvania, was convicted of beating a 70-year-old man to death after the two got in a fight and the elder man hit Roscoli with a hockey stick. Roscoli pleaded guilty and will be spending as many as five years behind state bars for involuntary manslaughter. How does five years for climbing a bridge seem now?
Schumer said in a press release that his bill makes it easier to target terrorists.
But Rao believes the city already has enough resources and laws to do that, and that this would be gratuitous.
"History has shown that trespass laws, in particular, have lent themselves to abuse and arbitrary (or racialized) enforcement by law enforcement, particularly in NYC," he writes.
It's already illegal in New York City to trespass or scale tall structures without permission. But Rao says that a lot of the "critical infrastructure" in New York is also hangout space where locals and tourists alike should be able to feel comfortable. "I do have a fear that this law could further criminalize and federalize innocuous conduct of city residents in both foreseeable and unforeseen ways."
Gabe Rottman, senior counsel at the ACLU, seems to agree. "We haven't seen the text of the bill," he says. "But [we] would certainly be concerned if it opens the door to selective enforcement against individuals expressing opinions critical of the government or could result in inconsistent enforcement because of the definition of 'critical infrastructure.' "
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.