LETTER OF THE WEEK
He was our sunshine
Re Robert Christgau's "Ray Charles 1930-2004" [June 16-22]: I sit here in utter amazement at the focus of the nation on the lionizing of a man who was a contemptuous bastard, instead of on Ray Charles. Charles never aspired to lead a nation nor achieve Faustian levels of power.
Simply put, Ray Charles was a man who struggled against his pain and demons in a manner that didn't take or destroy lives. He brought joy and healing to others even while he continued to endure his own shadows and darkness.
Thank you, Robert Christgau, for shedding light on this great man, and thanks of course to you, Ray Charles.
Plattsburgh, New York
Re Robert Sietsema's "100 Best Italian Restaurants" [June 9-15]:
Due to my Italian American heritage, I know real Italian food. Sietsema is totally mistaken about two places he considers the best Italian restaurants in Staten Island. He listed Joe and Pat's (33) and Denino's (39) as good Italian restaurants. All they are good for is their pizza. The reason people claim they make good Italian food is because they are not Italian and don't know shit about real Italian food.
The restaurants that should have been included are Italianissimo (on McClean Avenue) and Trattoria Romana and Nino's (both on Hylan Boulevard). These are the only true Italian restaurants in Staten Island, and your review missed out on them.
Duncan Hills, Staten Island
Commendations and Confirmations
Re Nat Hentoff's "Wallace v. Schumer" [May 5-11]:
I want to commend Hentoff on speaking the truth on the Pickering cross-burning issue. I am a longtime democratic socialist, but I do not believe that character assassination has any place in politics. Shame on you, Chuck Schumer, for not admitting you made a mistake. Perhaps Judge Pickering should in fact be confirmed.
Ed Park's discussion of lacunal art in "The Connections: A Selective History of Instant Inspiration" [Books, June 2-8] reminded me of a passage in Oulipian permanent provisional secretary Marcel Bénabou's recent To Write on Tamara? During the narrator's brief, youthful "affair" with Violetta, she sends him verses from Baudelaire's Fleurs du Mal with "certain words . . . circled in red and situated on the page in such a way as to constitute genuine little poems within the original poems . . . even more explicit in their invitation." Bénabou does not elaborate, so I humbly submit the following possibilities: "man/your/billows surging without end/You plunge/hug it/moan/two/eternal wrestlers" ("Man and the Sea"); "naked/Naked" ("Jewels"); and the unambiguous "Ill Luck": "So huge/long/I come."
Ed Park replies: Hot stuff, Mary. Another "connection" has since revealed itself to me: A Humumental sample adorns the cover of David Lodge's Consciousness and the Novel, just out in paper from Harvard. Before a female head floats a sentence worthy of Gertrude Stein: "He thought/June/thought/the only/thought/known to him."
Re Jonathan Adams's "Generation Debt: Kiss Your Career Goodbye" [June 16-22]:
I understand the lack of engagement with politicians and their promises among these young women. Women and children are always hot topics in election years. Then issues like the health needs of the poor (working or otherwise) either disappear or become rhetoric for in-house deal-making among those elected. Unless the voters can afford very expensive lobbyists, rarely do the issues they voted on get addressed. My husband and I have reared our children, and although we had to work very hard to provide for them and our retirement, we began with a better playing field than those in your column who now struggle just to stay afloat. It's a travesty that they sink without notice from those they elected on broken promises.
Egging Them On
Re "Fessing Up: How Guilty Is the Times?" [June 2-8]:
I feel I must quibble a bit with a few of my dear friend Richard Goldstein's recent observations in your Press Clips column. I think it is utterly irrelevant to cry "sexism" in regard to Lynndie England's exposure as one of the many torturers at Abu Ghraib prison. No doubt the treatment of prisoners throughout the gulag the U.S. has constructed around the world is just as barbaric as what we see in the digital photos that have been reproduced everywhere, and Ms. England is hardly the brains behind the policy of ditching the Geneva Conventions. Nevertheless, "just obeying orders," however loosely interpreted, doesn't excuse anyone, male or female, for egregious crimes against humanity.
My second quibble concerns the question "How guilty is the Times?" raised in the subhead. Ask Wen Ho Lee, whose interrogators brandished the front page of the Times when it was splashed with allegations against him that his interrogators had themselves fed to "the paper of record." The only apologies the Times extended when Wen Ho Lee was exonerated were to members of its own staff who might have taken the paper's half-assed apologies for itself personally.
Did they cause the war, or did the supine public the Times helped create with a flood of disinformation? Which came first, chicken or egg?
Mergers and Acquisitions
Re James Ridgeway's "The Second Coming" [June 2-8]:
If John Kerry acquires John McCain as his running mate, we can finally stop pretending there is any difference between Democrats and Republicans. America has had a one-party political system for quite a while now. Might as well make it official.
Upper West Side
Re Sharon Lerner's "Awkward Kerry, Hopeless Bush" [June 16-22]:
The statements made by the single women have more bite than Lerner's piece. Though Lerner includes their statements, she gives little support to them, nor does she openly challenge the candidates to address their issues.
I am a single woman and have been old enough to vote since 1978. At no time have I found any candidate worth voting for. The day a political candidate fights for the hearts of individuals regardless of race, gender, sexuality, or religion will be the day that not only women but all voters will return to voting.
It's time to give women and all people a candidate who has the resolve to actually fight for what the basic individual requires for a respectful existence. Our focus cannot solely be on women or single women, but all of humanity.
Plattsburgh, New York
Sharon Lerner makes an interesting point. Until recently, young women actually voted in great numbers compared to young men. Yet all these years, no one seemed very concerned that the large majority of young men were not voting. I don't recall seeing the onslaught of articles that I now see addressing the problem of young women. Why is this? There is some hypocrisy here.
As the statistics Lerner provides show, the voting habits of both young men and young women are pitiful. We should be concerned that young people in general are not voting. In fact, we should be concerned that Americans are generally not voting.
I understand that the political parties are going to target age and gender groups that they feel will vote for them, but why must The Village Voice target voters too?
Ta-Nehisi Coates's "Doing It With R. Kelly" [June 15, villagevoice.com] was excellent. I wish the rest of the populace would get it. His lyrics are so juvenile and nasty. I long for the '70s again.
Robin C. Rock
The Defense Rests
Re "Doing It With R. Kelly":
I don't know what your musical tastes are, but as far as r&b is concerned, R. Kelly is the truth. You only have to listen to music today to realize that Kelly is a cut above the rest. He is a man of contradictions and is not afraid to expose his fans to his tortured spirit. When I listen to R. Kelly, I identify with a struggle for spirituality that is often overcome by a primal urge to get down and dirty. Maybe you are just too repressed to truly get and feel the essence of songs like "12 Play" and "Your Body's Calling." Maybe you've never felt so alone in this world that you literally needed a hug. You stand and judge R. Kelly, deeming him guilty as though you were privy to all the facts and evidence that surround his highly publicized case. You may not like him as a person. He may, in your eyes, be guilty of what he is charged with, but to deny him his musical prowess is downright ridiculous.
Halifax, Nova Scotia
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Village Voice's biggest stories.
- The Man Behind 'Modern Seinfeld,' Focuses on His Own Neuroses in New Book
- NYU Student Employees Say the University Hasn't Paid Them in Months
- Here Are the Early Frontrunners for Worst Halloween Costumes for Sale in New York