LETTER OF THE WEEK
So zen: Batman is Batman
Michael Atkinson puts on his most dour, scowling mien in order to accuse Batman Begins of being too dour and scowling ["Cape and Scowl," June 15-21]. Wait, he was going to see a movie version of a comic book, right? "[T]hose looking for a taste of Memento's radical perspective amid the stunts and CGIs will feel bereft." My goodness, I should hope so.
Those looking for Memento should watch Memento. Those hoping that a Batman movie magically manages to be something other than a Batman movie should perhaps stay at home and practice zen mind, acceptance of the universal condition.
Re Nick Sylvester's "Mondo Kim's Busted for Bootlegs" [villagevoice.com, June 10]: Mix tapes are not a cancer to the music industry. Just because a CD-R mix tape in Mondo Kim's record store carries a three-minute mix of 50 Cent surrounded by dozens of other more talented artists who wouldn't get exposure otherwise and one major-label record company takes offense to that doesn't mean the Feds should raid a place that tries to do what major-label music companies stopped doing long ago: Find kickass music and expose people to talent.
Los Angeles, California
Not revolution, devolution
Thanks to Nat Hentoff for writing "Castro's Black Prisoner" [June 15-21]. As a lifelong New Yorker, and Cuban American pro-democracy activist, I never thought I would see the day when the Voice would finally defend a true human rights dissident in Cuba (Dr. Biscet) and actually tell it like it is regarding Fidel Castro's crimes against the Cuban people.
I remember my father telling me when I was a child in the 1970s that your paper, although OK for movie, art gallery, food, and cultural listings, was a leftist one that praised tyrants and the Cuban Revolution. I also want to commend Hentoff for defending the brave Cuban Independent Library movementas well as lambasting (rightfully so) the reactionary baby boomer hierarchy at the American Library Association which has a dysfunctional infatuation with Fidel Castro's dystopian devolution in the tropics.
Michael Atkinson is way off in his review of Batman Begins ["Cape and Scowl," June 15-21]: Hands down, one of the best films of the year and definitely one of the best comic book adaptations ever. The performances, the writing, the directionit all worked. This is the first time I have ever so strongly disagreed with a critic that I immediately wrote a response.
Los Angeles, California
Batwords and forwards
I couldn't tell if Atkinson liked Batman Begins or not. His vocabulary is vast, but his sentences are mazes. Also, are these words really necessary for a review of Batman: solemnity, tortuous, mano a manos, scion, ludicrous contortions, regalia, ad infinitum, Dolby-bludgeoned tympanic cavity, effete, insofar?
Holy Bananas! I believe in artistic expression, but I can't even understand what he was writing!
Atkinson's Batman Begins review was actually the most refreshing I have read of a summer blockbusterever. Thank you for actually giving a bit of insight into the makings of the movie as opposed to just regurgitating the plot.
St. Louis, Missouri
The fallacy lies
As regards the review of Batman Begins, one of the most poignant unstated arguments is that it repudiates all the prior films in the Batman franchise. Batman begins anew. There lies the fallacy of Atkinson's review. As it is a new treatment of an old franchise it must be evaluated on its own merits. And upon those merits it is a triumph.
The simpleton Bruce Wayne of the prior installments is now given the intense multi-layered psychological treatment that the one and only non-superpowered superhero de-serves. It gives us Batman v.2. It is a wonderful film.
Las Vegas, Nevada
I can't help but wonder if the coming student loan, interest rate hike Anya Kamenetz wrote about ["High Interest in Low Interest," June 15-21] is somehow related to the recent army-recruiting shortfalls. To increase enlistments, the government might increase pay to soldiers, or increase the cost of college. If my vote still counts, I vote that student loans not be used to support the war on terror.
I love Dan Savage's column. I have been an avid reader since I was 16 years old. Now I am 21. It has been so helpful in so many ways. I am a somewhat single, heterosexual male that enjoys pegging and thinks it would be great to have a threesome with a woman and a man. Only his column could have given me the confidence and the knowledge to ever have the courage to pull something like that off. I have engaged in pegging with my former Catholic high school, female art teacher who is 13 years older than me. She also enjoys reading the column. Savage has discussed topics that need to be discussed, like homosexual rights. Dan, I want to praise you for being an amazing person who actually uses his brain. I wish I had some naked pictures of Ashton Kutcher to send you.
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Clear your deep throat
Re "FBI Cleared W. Mark Felt of Watergate Leaks," by Murray Waas [villagevoice.com, June 10]: I was wondering why the "mainstream media" haven't been all over the Albany Times Union story Waas refers to, which says that Deep Throat was sort of an internal FBI committee chaired by Mark Felt. The story in question was based on hearsay. That is, an FBI agent said he had been told by a participant etc. The story's certainly plausible, and I'd bet it's right, but the source was not a participant, and that's why the "mainstream media" have been perhaps slow in matching it. Presumably, it will be sorted out, and with solid attribution.
Glen Ridge, New Jersey
That is the question
I enjoyed Elizabeth Mendez Berry's review of Common's Be ["Candid Camera," June 15-21] until the last paragraph. My reactions to a few of the points made earlier prepared me for what I felt would have been the last bite of a delicious dessert after an exquisite dinner. But instead I was served a stale Krispy Kreme. She missed the point and purpose of Be.
All of what she said was missing on this album can be found on one track, "Chi-City." She mentions the track for its production value earlier in the article. But it's that track that has that "wink," and it's that track where Common is telling everyone he still has that love, that fire, and that lyrically there aren't too many out there on his level.
The purpose of Be is just that: to be. It's his take on that lost California dream, that girl in the club he'd love to spend time with, smoking a Dutch with a friend on the block. And most importantly, he tells those after him, and everyone who understands the struggle, that in the end, no matter what you've been told in the past, the truth is this world is yours for the taking. This release is in fact revolutionary, as Berry stated, in this late bling era of hip-hop. But in her attempt to understand who this rapper has come to be (no pun intended), she lost sight of the fact that this album trims the excess of his releases in the pastno skits, just great production, memorable lines, and true hip-hop.
Passaic, New Jersey
Not circling the Square
Thank you, Jarrett Murphy, for an excellent story on Washington Square Park ["Extreme Makeover," June 8-14]. You truly covered all sides. It's the best so far.
President, MacDougal Street North Block Association
As a conservative Christian I believe Nat Hentoff's column "Bush's Moral Guide" [June 1-7] is right on the mark regarding Darfur. Unlike some of my fellow travelers I hesitate to definitively answer Hentoff's question, What would Jesus do? but I suspect that He would consider the actual suffering in Darfur a higher priority than potential suffering in the U.S. I certainly do.
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter Our daily newsletter delivers quick clicks to keep you in the know
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in New York, delivered to your inbox.